Based on your book
A Babysitter's Guide to Monster Hunting #2
by Ballarini, Joe
Kelly Ferguson is back, and she is learning that keeping kids safe is far more complicated when the bedtime stories are actually real. This second installment keeps the momentum of the first book going, throwing Kelly into a wider, weirder world where the monsters are craftier and the stakes feel personal. The writing is snappy and quick, never letting the narrative drag as it moves through suburban secret societies and high-stakes supernatural skirmishes. It feels like a late-night adventure with your best friends, balancing genuine danger with a cheeky, irreverent sense of humor. If you enjoy stories where the mundane world hides a sprawling magical infrastructure and you like your heroes brave, capable, and slightly sarcastic, this is a perfect fit. It is an ideal read for anyone who wants a fast-paced quest that values friendship over everything else.
10 Books similar to 'A Babysitter's Guide to Monster Hunting #2'
If the thrill of discovering a hidden supernatural society under our noses is what keeps you turning pages, these selections are for you. I chose these books because they perfectly capture that specific feeling of kids being the only ones who can save the day when the adults are completely oblivious. Whether you are looking for more suburban monster skirmishes, secret magical preserves, or the camaraderie of a found family fighting against impossible odds, these stories echo the same sense of wonder and high-stakes adventure found in Kelly's world.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
by Max Brallier
Like the Babysitter's Guide series, this book features a group of ordinary kids thrust into an extraordinary battle against monsters in their own neighborhood. It perfectly captures that blend of humor, high-stakes action, and the 'us against the world' camaraderie that fans of Ballarini's work will adore.
by Neil Gaiman
This classic tale explores a hidden, slightly creepy world parallel to our own, mirroring the secret monster society found in Ballarini's books. It offers a slightly darker, more atmospheric take on the 'kid vs. supernatural forces' dynamic that fans of monster hunting will appreciate.
by Rick Riordan
This book is the gold standard for 'ordinary kid discovers a hidden magical world' narratives. Fans of the monster-hunting premise will enjoy the fast-paced action, witty dialogue, and the way mythology is cleverly woven into modern life.
by Brandon Mull
Fablehaven introduces readers to a secret preserve for magical creatures, offering a similar sense of discovery and danger found in the Babysitter's Guide. It features relatable protagonists who must navigate complex rules and perilous encounters with beasts.
Love to read on the go?
Explore Kindle e-readers and take your books with you.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
by Tony DiTerlizzi and Holly Black
This series excels at depicting the intersection of the mundane world and a dangerous, hidden realm of faeries and monsters. It shares the same 'kids uncovering secrets that adults ignore' motif that drives the plot of the Babysitter's Guide.
While slightly more suspenseful, this series features young protagonists fighting supernatural entities in a world where only kids have the ability to see them. Fans of Ballarini will appreciate the clever world-building and the focus on young people taking charge of dangerous situations.
by Kate Milford
This book offers a cozy yet mysterious atmosphere, focusing on a house that serves as a hub for smugglers and strange guests. Readers who enjoy the 'secret society' and 'monster hunting' aspects of Ballarini's books will enjoy the puzzle-solving and magical realism here.
by Kevin Bolger
This is a fun, slightly gross, and action-packed story about a boy who accidentally brings a stuffed animal to life as a zombie. It shares the same 'monsters in the suburbs' energy and lighthearted, fast-paced narrative style that fans of the Babysitter's Guide enjoy.
by Sarah Mlynowski, Lauren Myracle, and Emily Jenkins
This series focuses on kids who don't quite fit into the standard mold of magic users, much like the unconventional monster hunters in Ballarini's books. It emphasizes the power of friendship and embracing one's unique abilities to overcome obstacles.
Combining supernatural adventure with a heartfelt story about family and heritage, this book is perfect for fans of monster hunting. It features a group of friends dealing with ghosts and ghouls, balancing humor with genuine stakes and emotional growth.
Not sure what they've already read?
Let them pick their next favorite with an Amazon Gift Card.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.