
Based on your book
by Garber, Stephanie
The conclusion to the Once Upon a Broken Heart trilogy finally forces Evangeline Fox to confront the jagged edges of her own fairy tale. After a series of heartbreaks and magically induced memory losses, she is trapped between the devastating allure of Jacks, the Prince of Hearts, and the reality of her own agency. The narrative leans heavily into the dreamlike, slightly gothic aesthetic Garber is known for, moving at a frantic, emotional pace that feels like a fever dream. It is less a straightforward quest and more an exploration of how much a person is willing to sacrifice for a love they are not even sure is real. You will enjoy this if you prefer your fantasy heavy on the romance, full of impossible bargains, and anchored by a protagonist who remains relentlessly hopeful despite the cruelty of the world around her.
Since you enjoyed the specific blend of high-stakes longing and whimsical danger in this series, these titles were curated to satisfy that same itch. Whether you are craving the morally grey tension found in The Cruel Prince or the lush, folklore-inspired atmosphere of Spinning Silver, these books focus on the intersection of grand romance and perilous magical bargains. We selected these stories because they feature characters who, like Evangeline, must navigate treacherous faerie courts and hidden worlds, ensuring that the emotional intensity of your reading experience remains just as sharp and immersive.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
by Holly Black
Fans of Garber's high-stakes faerie romance will appreciate the dangerous, atmospheric world-building and the intense, morally grey enemies-to-lovers dynamic. It captures that same feeling of being trapped in a beautiful but deadly magical court where trust is a liability.
This book mirrors the fairy-tale retelling structure and the lush, romantic prose found in the 'Once Upon a Broken Heart' series. It features a strong heroine navigating a dangerous, magical landscape where love and curses are inextricably linked.
If you loved the whimsical, magical aesthetic and the central romance of Garber's work, this book is a perfect match. It offers an enchanting, immersive atmosphere where magic feels tangible and the stakes of love are incredibly high.
by Naomi Novik
This novel excels at the same kind of dark, folklore-inspired storytelling that defines Garber's writing. It features complex female protagonists navigating bargains and magical entities, delivering a satisfying blend of romance and high-stakes adventure.

Not sure what they've already read?
Let them pick their next favorite with an Amazon Gift Card.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
Readers who enjoy the blend of magic, mystery, and swoon-worthy romance will find this standalone fantasy delightful. It features a spirited protagonist, a dangerous magical world, and a slow-burn relationship that fans of Evangeline Fox will adore.
by Rebecca Ross
This book captures the deeply emotional, romantic core of Garber's work while introducing a compelling, slightly more grounded fantasy setting. The connection between the leads is intense and heartfelt, perfect for those who loved the emotional stakes in 'A Curse for True Love'.
This is a quintessential pick for fans of faerie bargains and romantic quests. It shares the whimsical yet perilous tone of Garber's writing, focusing on a human girl and a faerie prince whose fates become dangerously intertwined.
If you enjoyed the morally ambiguous, ambitious nature of characters in Garber's world, this book is an excellent follow-up. It features a cunning protagonist plotting to marry a king, blending dark romance with sharp wit.
For readers who loved the gothic, atmospheric, and slightly eerie elements of the 'Caraval' and 'Once Upon a Broken Heart' series, this retelling offers a perfect blend of mystery and magic. It is haunting, romantic, and beautifully written.
by V.E. Schwab
This book shares the lyrical, slightly melancholic, and magical atmosphere that Garber creates so well. It is a story about hidden worlds and family legacies that will resonate with readers who enjoy stories where the setting is as important as the romance.

Prefer to listen?
Try Audible and hear the story instead of reading it.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.