Based on your book
A Good Girl's Guide to Murder
by Jackson, Holly
Pippa Fitz-Amobi decides to use her final year school project to re-examine a closed local murder case that everyone else in town is desperate to forget. While the police are convinced the culprit is already dead, Pippa finds inconsistencies that suggest the real killer is still walking the streets of her quiet hometown. The book moves with the relentless pace of a true-crime podcast, mixing transcripts, logs, and interview notes that make the reader feel like a partner in the investigation. It is sharp, analytical, and leans heavily into the tension of being an amateur detective in a place where people will lie to keep their secrets buried. If you enjoy puzzle-heavy mysteries where the protagonist is smarter than the adults in the room and you appreciate a story that balances high school social dynamics with genuine danger, this is for you.
10 Books similar to 'A Good Girl's Guide to Murder'
Since you enjoyed the blend of amateur sleuthing and high-stakes secrets in Pippa's investigation, these ten titles were selected to scratch that same itch. Whether it is the podcast-style narrative of Sadie, the academic puzzles in Truly Devious, or the high-pressure social dynamics in One of Us Is Lying, each pick captures the specific thrill of unmasking a killer from within a closed community. These books favor characters who take matters into their own hands, mirroring the analytical intensity and the race-against-time urgency that makes the search for truth so addictive.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
Much like AGGGTM, this novel blends high school dynamics with a central murder mystery that forces the protagonists to uncover dark secrets about their peers. It features a similar fast-paced narrative and a group of students who must work together to clear their names.
This book follows a true-crime aficionado who enrolls in a remote boarding school to solve a cold case, mirroring Pippa's investigative obsession. The dual-timeline structure and academic setting offer a sophisticated puzzle that fans of Jackson's work will find deeply engaging.
by Kara Thomas
This thriller delves into the aftermath of a series of tragic deaths in a small town, focusing on a protagonist who starts digging into the past despite warnings to stop. It captures the same feeling of a community hiding ugly truths behind a polished exterior.
This gripping story utilizes a podcast format within the narrative to track a girl's journey to find her sister's killer, echoing the investigative podcast element that made AGGGTM so popular. It is a raw, emotional, and intense look at justice and obsession.
Love to read on the go?
Explore Kindle e-readers and take your books with you.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
Set in an elite private school, this thriller exposes systemic secrets and dangerous conspiracies that threaten the lives of the main characters. Fans of the high-stakes, investigative nature of AGGGTM will appreciate the tension and the unraveling of a complex mystery.
While less of a murder mystery and more of a puzzle-based thriller, this book features an ordinary girl thrust into a world of immense wealth and dangerous family secrets. The intellectual challenge and the need to decipher clues resonate strongly with the tone of Pippa's investigations.
by Diana Urban
This locked-room style mystery traps a group of high schoolers together, forcing them to confront their past actions and secrets to survive. It matches the high-tension, character-driven mystery style found in Holly Jackson's writing.
This modern reimagining of Sherlock Holmes features two descendants of the famous duo forced to solve a murder at their boarding school. It captures the same 'amateur detective' spirit and intellectual camaraderie that fans of AGGGTM love.
by Abigail Haas
This psychological thriller focuses on a murder accusation during a spring break trip, relying heavily on unreliable narration and the slow reveal of evidence. It shares the same 'unraveling the truth' satisfaction that defines the reading experience of AGGGTM.
by Ellie Marney
Featuring a teenage protagonist working with the FBI to interview a serial killer, this book provides a darker, more intense look at criminal investigation. Readers who enjoyed the investigative process and the 'danger close' stakes of AGGGTM will find this equally compelling.
Not sure what they've already read?
Let them pick their next favorite with an Amazon Gift Card.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.