Based on your book
by Penny Reid
Marie Harris is done with the online dating merry-go-round. She's so utterly fed up, she's decided to tackle her needs with a more logical, almost scientific approach: professional cuddlers, life coaches, and other paid services. It's a truly funny premise, watching her methodically try to optimize her personal life away from romantic entanglements. But then, a truly memorable, and initially irritating, man from a past disastrous date re-enters her world, shaking up her carefully constructed theories. This book delivers a romance built on brainy humor, sharp, rapid-fire banter, and a wonderfully quirky group of friends. It's a slow, satisfying burn for readers who love a smart heroine who thinks her way through love, and enjoy a story where the emotional connection feels deeply earned and genuinely charming.
If you loved Dating-ish for its smart, often hilarious take on modern romance, driven by a sharp-witted heroine and an unconventional enemies-to-lovers dynamic, you'll find similar delight in our curated list. We've gathered books that share that delightful intellectual sparring and the satisfying slow-burn build of emotional connection. Whether it's the professional rivalry turning to affection in "The Hating Game" and "Love on the Brain," or the unique ways characters get to know each other in "The Flatshare" and "Attachment," these recommendations all celebrate strong female leads navigating love with humor and genuine emotional depth.
We earn from qualifying purchases through our affiliate partners, including Amazon and Bookshop.org.
by Sally Thorne
Like Dating-ish, this novel features a sharp-witted, intellectual dynamic between two rivals who struggle to navigate their professional and personal feelings. It captures the same blend of high-tension banter and deep emotional vulnerability found in Penny Reid's writing.
by Beth O'Leary
This story mirrors the unconventional relationship building and slow-burn pacing of Dating-ish. It focuses on two people getting to know each other through unique circumstances, emphasizing personal growth and emotional connection over immediate physical attraction.
Fans of the analytical and observational nature of Dating-ish will appreciate how this book explores connection through technology and written communication. It features a nerdy, introspective hero and a slow-building romance that feels both realistic and intellectually stimulating.
by Helen Hoang
Much like Marie in Dating-ish, the protagonist here is highly intelligent and approaches romance with a logical, almost scientific mindset. The book balances steamy moments with a tender exploration of neurodiversity and emotional intimacy.
For couples who love each other but hate planning
From chaos to calm — instant AI wedding planning, no accounts, no stress.
From the makers of Similar Book Finder
This book features the 'grumpy/sunshine' dynamic and intellectual clashing that Penny Reid fans adore. It highlights a strong-willed heroine and a highly organized hero who must find common ground, leading to a deeply satisfying emotional payoff.
Set in a STEM environment, this novel shares the 'smart romance' vibe of the Knitting in the City series. It features a brilliant female lead and explores the complexities of professional rivalry turning into genuine affection through a series of misunderstandings.
by Emily Henry
This story focuses on a career-driven woman who, like Marie, is often misunderstood by others. The sharp, fast-paced dialogue and the subversion of typical romance tropes will resonate with readers who enjoy Penny Reid's more analytical approach to the genre.
by Jen DeLuca
Featuring a unique setting and a slow-burn attraction based on intellectual sparring, this book captures the 'vibe' of a Penny Reid novel. It explores the masks people wear in public versus their true selves, much like the dating app premise in Dating-ish.
by Tessa Dare
While historical, Tessa Dare’s voice is remarkably modern and witty, echoing Penny Reid’s humor. The relationship is built on mutual respect and intellectual compatibility, featuring a hero who is challenged by the heroine's sharp mind.
by Linda Holmes
This novel offers a more grounded and realistic look at friendship turning into love. It mirrors the emotional depth and the 'slice of life' feel of Dating-ish, focusing on two adults dealing with their pasts while navigating a new connection.
Love to read on the go?
Explore Kindle e-readers and take your books with you.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
We earn from qualifying purchases through our affiliate partners, including Amazon and Bookshop.org.