Finlay Donovan Is Killing It

Fans will love the chaotic energy and the 'accidental crime' plot that mirrors Finlay's predicament. It balances dark humor with high-stakes family loyalty in a way that feels both hilarious and tense.

Stephanie Plum is the spiritual predecessor to Finlay Donovan, featuring a relatable, slightly messy woman who stumbles into a dangerous profession. The witty narration and fast-paced suburban hijinks will feel instantly familiar.

Much like Finlay, Molly is an underestimated protagonist who finds herself at the center of a murder investigation. The book shares a unique narrative voice and a blend of mystery with heartwarming character development.

This story features a protagonist who returns home only to be framed for murder, necessitating some amateur sleuthing to clear her name. It captures the same 'regular person in over their head' vibe with a strong focus on community and humor.

While the protagonists are older, the sharp wit and the clever subversion of mystery tropes will appeal to Finlay Donovan fans. It balances a genuine puzzle with laugh-out-loud observations about life and mortality.

This book features a meddling, strong-willed woman who takes a crime investigation into her own hands with hilarious results. The focus on found family and the lighthearted tone makes it a perfect companion read.

This novel takes the 'ordinary women in extraordinary criminal situations' concept to the next level with retired assassins. It offers the same blend of humor, female friendship, and fast-paced action found in Cosimano’s work.

Darynda Jones delivers a sharp-tongued female lead and a mystery filled with quirky small-town energy. The balance of humor, romance, and suspense mirrors the tonal shifts that make Finlay's story so engaging.

For readers who enjoyed the darker, satirical edge of Finlay’s 'contract killer' misunderstanding, this book offers a biting and witty look at crime. It features a cynical but captivating female lead navigating complex family dynamics.

This book excels at blending suburban domesticity with a compelling murder mystery and sharp social commentary. Fans of Finlay’s struggles with motherhood and social expectations will appreciate the similar themes and witty prose.