I'd Tell You I Love You, But Then I'd Have to Kill You

Based on your book

I'd Tell You I Love You, But Then I'd Have to Kill You

by Ally Carter

Cammie Morgan isn't your average teenager; she's a spy-in-training at the elite Gallagher Academy, where classes include Advanced Covert Operations and various forms of combat. Life is pretty predictable until she meets Josh, a completely normal boy from town. Suddenly, Cammie has to figure out how to have a first crush and maintain her hidden identity, all while navigating the usual high school drama with a very unusual twist. This book is a pure delight, offering a reading experience that's both genuinely witty and wonderfully lighthearted. It moves at a brisk, adventurous pace, balancing thrilling spy missions with the sweet, sometimes awkward, pangs of first love. If you enjoy clever heroines, the excitement of secret societies, and a story that blends strong female friendships with a charming romance, you'll love spending time at Gallagher Academy.

10 Books similar to 'I'd Tell You I Love You, But Then I'd Have to Kill You'

If you adored the cleverness and charm of I'd Tell You I Love You, But Then I'd Have to Kill You, you'll find plenty to love in our curated list. We looked for books that capture that same spark of secret identities, whether they're spies, thieves, or gifted individuals. You'll discover more witty protagonists navigating unique boarding school settings, often balancing thrilling adventures with the complexities of first love and strong friendships. These recommendations offer that same blend of lighthearted fun, mystery, and compelling characters you enjoyed with Cammie Morgan.

We earn from qualifying purchases through our affiliate partners, including Amazon and Bookshop.org.

Heist Society
Heist Society

by Ally Carter

Fans will love the familiar witty voice and fast-paced adventure as a teen thief navigates a secret world, much like Cammie's spy life. It shares the charm, cleverness, and strong female lead, just with a different kind of "secret identity."

The Naturals
The Naturals

by Jennifer Lynn Barnes

This series features a group of exceptionally talented teenagers recruited into a secret FBI program, mirroring the idea of a specialized school for extraordinary individuals. Readers will enjoy the blend of mystery, romance, and a strong female lead uncovering dark secrets.

Truly Devious
Truly Devious

by Maureen Johnson

Set at a prestigious, quirky boarding school, this book offers a compelling mystery with a sharp, witty protagonist, reminiscent of Cammie's intelligence and the unique Gallagher Academy setting. It combines intricate puzzles with engaging character dynamics and a touch of romance.

A Study in Charlotte
A Study in Charlotte

by Brittany Cavallaro

For fans who enjoyed the boarding school setting, witty banter, and a dash of danger, this modern Sherlock Holmes retelling delivers. It features a brilliant, somewhat reckless female lead and a complex relationship, echoing the blend of intellect, emotion, and intrigue in Ally Carter's work.

Amazon Gift Card

Not sure what they've already read?

Let them pick their next favorite with an Amazon Gift Card.

Shop Gift Cards

As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

Alex Rider: Stormbreaker
Alex Rider: Stormbreaker

by Anthony Horowitz

While featuring a male protagonist, this book captures the essence of a teenager thrust into the dangerous world of espionage, much like Cammie's adventures. It's packed with thrilling action, high stakes, and a reluctant hero forced to use their wits to survive.

The Princess Diaries
The Princess Diaries

by Meg Cabot

This charming series shares the lighthearted tone, humor, and "secret identity" trope that makes the Gallagher Girls so enjoyable, albeit with royalty instead of spies. Readers will connect with Mia's journey of self-discovery, friendship, and first love in a fish-out-of-water scenario.

Anna and the French Kiss
Anna and the French Kiss

by Stephanie Perkins

If you loved the boarding school setting and the sweet, engaging romance of "I'd Tell You I Love You," this book offers a similar heartwarming experience. It perfectly captures the excitement of first love, new friendships, and finding your place in a charming new environment.

The Inheritance Games
The Inheritance Games

by Jennifer Lynn Barnes

This book features a clever, strong female protagonist who is suddenly thrust into a world of wealth, secrets, and dangerous puzzles, echoing the mystery and intrigue found in Cammie's world. It's a fast-paced read with witty banter, unexpected twists, and a compelling romantic tension.

Miss Peregrine's Home for Peculiar Children

by Ransom Riggs

For readers who enjoyed the unique boarding school setting and the sense of a hidden world, this book offers a darker, more fantastical take on children with extraordinary abilities. It combines mystery, adventure, and the formation of a found family in a truly atmospheric setting.

The School for Good and Evil
The School for Good and Evil

by Soman Chainani

This series presents a fantastical boarding school where students are trained for their roles in fairy tales, offering a similar "special school" vibe with strong female friendships and a journey of self-discovery. It's whimsical, adventurous, and explores complex themes of good versus evil.