
Based on your book
by Rio, M. L.
Seven Shakespearean actors at an elite conservatory spend their days reciting the Bard and their nights living out his tragedies. The line between their rehearsals and their reality begins to dissolve, transforming their tight-knit bond into a claustrophobic web of obsession, jealousy, and eventually, murder. This is a story about the performance of friendship and the devastating cost of taking art too seriously. You are reading from the perspective of Oliver, who is looking back at these events years after serving his prison sentence, which makes the narrative feel both intimate and hauntingly unreliable. It is slow-burn, atmospheric, and deeply melancholic. If you enjoy stories where the setting is a character in itself and you like picking apart the psychology of morally grey people who think they are the heroes of their own ruin, this will stay with you long after the final act.
Since you enjoyed the specific blend of toxic intellectualism and insular group dynamics in this story, I have curated a list of books that explore similar themes. These selections lean into the idea of the elite academic circle where loyalty is weaponized and secrets become a heavy burden. Whether it is the obsession with competitive games in Black Chalk or the psychological infiltration found in The Likeness, these titles mirror the way our characters lost their innocence. They are perfect for when you want to remain in that dark, scholarly headspace.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
by Donna Tartt
As the definitive inspiration for the dark academia genre, this novel shares the intense, obsessive atmosphere and intellectual focus found in If We Were Villains. Readers will recognize the same tight-knit group of students whose deep bonds and shared secrets spiral into moral decay and tragedy.
This novel captures the gritty, secretive nature of elite academic circles while adding a layer of dark, supernatural mystery. Fans of Rio's work will appreciate the exploration of power dynamics and the intense, isolating pressure of being an outsider within a prestigious institution.
by Tana French
This psychological thriller focuses on a detective who infiltrates a tight-knit group of graduate students, mirroring the intense, insular, and performative nature of the characters in If We Were Villains. The narrative excels at exploring the seductive power of belonging to a closed, intellectual circle.

Love to read on the go?
Explore Kindle e-readers and take your books with you.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
This book features a brilliant, precocious protagonist who becomes entangled with a charismatic teacher and a clique of students, echoing the intense mentor-student relationships and intellectual pretension of Rio's work. It is a complex, literary mystery that demands close attention to detail.
by Lev Grossman
While it leans into fantasy, the core of the story focuses on the disillusionment of students at an elite, secretive college, capturing the same 'found family' dynamics that turn toxic. It resonates with fans who enjoy stories about young people grappling with ambition, identity, and the heavy cost of their desires.
This thriller centers on a group of students at Oxford who begin a game of dares that quickly spirals into dangerous, life-altering consequences. It mirrors the 'if we were villains' premise of a group whose shared history and intellectual games lead to a tragic, irreversible end.
by John Knowles
This classic novel explores the intense, often competitive friendship between two boys at a boarding school, touching on themes of jealousy, guilt, and the loss of innocence. Fans of the emotional weight and dramatic character studies in If We Were Villains will find this equally poignant.
by Katy Hays
Set in the world of high-stakes academia and art history, this novel follows a young woman who gets swept up in a dangerous, obsessive circle of researchers. The atmosphere is thick with secrets, ambition, and the same kind of intellectual intensity that drives the characters in Rio's novel.
by K.M. Golland
While lighter in tone, this book explores the complexities of intense, lifelong friendships and the secrets that threaten to tear them apart. It appeals to readers who are drawn to the deep, complicated interpersonal relationships and the emotional fallout that occurs when those bonds are tested.

Not sure what they've already read?
Let them pick their next favorite with an Amazon Gift Card.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.