
Based on your book
by Lukens, F.T.
Prince Tal is supposed to be a figurehead, bound by royal expectations and the need to keep his budding magical abilities a secret. When he embarks on his coming-of-age tour, he expects a boring voyage, but a chance encounter with a mysterious, charming stranger named Athlen changes everything. As Tal finds himself drawn to the boy who seems to appear wherever there is water, he uncovers a plot that threatens the kingdom and forces him to embrace his true self. This is a bright, breezy adventure that prioritizes heart over heavy angst. It feels like a sunny, high-seas romance where the tension comes from the stakes of discovery rather than grim despair. If you want a story that balances lighthearted fantasy with a genuinely sweet slow-burn, this is your next weekend read.
Since you enjoyed the playful banter and the blend of high-seas adventure with a deeply personal romance, these selections were curated to keep that specific energy alive. Whether you are craving more cozy, magical world-building found in books like The House in the Cerulean Sea or looking for that same crackling enemies-to-lovers tension found in Carry On, these stories share a commitment to queer joy and character-led growth. They lean into the tropes of hidden identities and found families, ensuring that the emotional payoff remains just as satisfying as the magical journey itself.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
by F.T. Lukens
Since this is by the same author, it carries the exact same blend of lighthearted fantasy, charming romance, and character-driven humor. It shares the 'found family' dynamic and the low-stakes, high-fun adventure style that makes Lukens' work so enjoyable.
by TJ Klune
This book captures the same cozy, magical atmosphere and emphasis on gentle, heartwarming relationships found in In Deeper Waters. Readers who loved the sweet, developing romance and the sense of discovery will find this equally delightful.
This novel features a similar blend of magical boarding school tropes, enemies-to-lovers dynamics, and a strong focus on the emotional growth of the protagonists. It mirrors the 'chosen one' narrative while keeping the focus firmly on the romantic connection.
by Aiden Thomas
Like In Deeper Waters, this story balances a unique magic system with a compelling, high-stakes romance that feels deeply personal. It shares the themes of identity and acceptance while maintaining a fast-paced, engaging plot.

Not sure what they've already read?
Let them pick their next favorite with an Amazon Gift Card.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
by Freya Marske
This book offers a slightly more mature but equally enchanting magical romance, featuring a forced proximity setup that fans of the prince/mage dynamic will appreciate. It blends historical setting with a captivating, slow-burn relationship.
by Mackenzi Lee
If you enjoyed the adventurous, travel-heavy plot and the banter-filled romance of In Deeper Waters, this historical romp is a perfect match. It captures the same sense of fun and the 'road trip' feeling of two characters falling in love while dealing with external threats.
This sci-fi romance mirrors the political intrigue and the 'arranged marriage' dynamic found in many fantasy romances, including Lukens' work. It focuses heavily on the emotional development of the two leads as they learn to trust one another.
by Alice Oseman
While it is a graphic novel, the emotional core, the sweetness of the romance, and the supportive friend groups are exactly what fans of In Deeper Waters are looking for. It is the gold standard for contemporary, gentle LGBTQ+ storytelling.
For readers who enjoyed the 'prince' and 'magic' elements of In Deeper Waters, this Arthurian retelling offers a fresh, queer perspective on classic tropes. It balances epic adventure with intimate character moments.
by C.S. Pacat
While slightly darker in tone, this book shares the high-stakes fantasy adventure and the intense, complex relationship dynamics that keep readers hooked. It is perfect for those who want a bit more grit alongside their magical romance.

Love to read on the go?
Explore Kindle e-readers and take your books with you.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.