Based on your book
by Tehlor Mejia
It Happened to Anna introduces us to Sadie Rivera, a girl literally haunted by a possessive ghost that sabotages any attempt she makes at friendship. After a devastating accident involving her best friend, Anna, Sadie is convinced her spectral companion is to blame. At a new school, she's determined to remain isolated, until the intriguing Mal arrives. For some reason, Mal doesn't trigger the ghost's wrath, but her friendship comes with its own unsettling demands. This book offers a deeply atmospheric and melancholy reading experience, slowly tightening the suspense as Sadie navigates a very real, very human threat alongside a supernatural one. It's a compelling pick for readers who appreciate a character-driven mystery with a dark, psychological edge, exploring the intensity and dangers of adolescent friendships.
If It Happened to Anna left you thinking about the blurred lines between friendship and obsession, and you appreciated its blend of a chilling mystery with the heavy weight of isolation and dark secrets, we have more for you. These books share that same compelling mix of a determined protagonist unraveling a cold case, often in a small town with a hidden past. You'll find stories about the intense psychological impact of trauma, the search for truth, and the lengths characters will go to understand or overcome adversity, all wrapped in that deeply atmospheric and sometimes unsettling tone.
We earn from qualifying purchases through our affiliate partners, including Amazon and Bookshop.org.
Like It Happened to Anna, this story follows a determined protagonist investigating a cold case involving a missing girl in a small town. It captures the same blend of obsessive investigation, dark secrets, and the personal toll of seeking justice.
This novel shares the gritty, emotional intensity of Mejia's work, focusing on a sister's desperate search for the truth behind a tragedy. The dual-perspective narrative and heavy themes of grief and vengeance will resonate deeply with fans.
by Kara Thomas
Fans of the 'small town with a dark past' vibe in It Happened to Anna will appreciate this story about a girl digging into a series of deaths that rocked her community years prior. It maintains a similarly claustrophobic and suspicious atmosphere.
This book mirrors the high-stakes emotional manipulation and the search for a lost loved one found in Mejia's writing. It explores the lengths one will go to rescue a sister from a dangerous situation while dealing with personal trauma.
Not sure what they've already read?
Let them pick their next favorite with an Amazon Gift Card.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
by E. Lockhart
Sharing the lyrical yet suspenseful tone of It Happened to Anna, this novel deals with memory, family trauma, and a shocking central mystery. It captures that same sense of unease and the slow unraveling of a devastating truth.
by Tess Sharpe
This thriller features a highly capable but traumatized female lead who must use her wits to survive a crisis, echoing the resilience seen in Anna's story. It is fast-paced and deeply rooted in the protagonist's complicated past.
For readers who appreciated the true-crime obsession and the haunting search for a predator in It Happened to Anna, this non-fiction account offers a similarly atmospheric and relentless pursuit of the truth.
This novel explores the complex bond between sisters and the psychological impact of a disappearance. Its focus on shifting identities and the blurred lines between truth and fiction matches the emotional weight of Mejia's narrative.
This book combines a chilling mystery with sharp social commentary, much like the thematic depth found in Mejia's work. It uses a small-town setting to explore how secrets and prejudice can lead to a breaking point.
Like It Happened to Anna, this is an intense, high-stakes story about a young woman caught in a dangerous situation involving power dynamics and a search for justice. It is emotionally raw and deeply compelling.
For couples who love each other but hate planning
From chaos to calm — instant AI wedding planning, no accounts, no stress.
From the makers of Similar Book Finder
We earn from qualifying purchases through our affiliate partners, including Amazon and Bookshop.org.