Based on your book
by Kylie Scott
Adele's return to her hometown for her father's wedding is less a joyful reunion and more a dreaded confrontation with her past. Years ago, as a young adult, she made a memorable, mortifying pass at Pete, her dad's business partner, creating a familial and professional earthquake. Now, a grown woman, she hopes to navigate the wedding with adult composure, but one look at Pete brings back a rush of old feelings. It Seemed Like a Good Idea at the Time is a wonderfully witty and passionate second-chance romance, brimming with sharp banter and the irresistible pull of first love. If you enjoy the delicious tension of a forbidden age-gap dynamic, a protagonist finding her footing, and the heartwarming journey of two people overcoming a truly awkward history, this one will keep you smiling.
If you appreciated the sharp wit and undeniable chemistry of Kylie Scott's It Seemed Like a Good Idea at the Time, then we have more stories that hit all the right notes. Our curated list focuses on the irresistible pull of forbidden love, often featuring an age-gap dynamic that adds delicious tension. You'll find protagonists navigating complex family ties and past mistakes, all while rediscovering a passionate connection. These books share that unique blend of heartwarming humor and deep emotional resonance, ensuring you'll find another story to fall for.
We earn from qualifying purchases through our affiliate partners, including Amazon and Bookshop.org.
Like Kylie Scott's novel, this book features a high-stakes age gap romance involving a protagonist falling for her father's contemporary. It captures the same tension of forbidden attraction and the emotional complexity of navigating family loyalty versus personal desire.
Fans of the slow-building tension and character-driven narrative in Scott's work will appreciate Zapata's mastery of the slow burn. This story focuses on the evolving relationship between two people in a professional setting that gradually becomes deeply personal.
This book mirrors the witty, slightly irreverent tone found in Kylie Scott's writing while exploring an unconventional age-gap dynamic. It balances humor with genuine emotional vulnerability and intense chemistry between the leads.
Similar to the 'return to roots' and family-centric themes in Scott's book, this story emphasizes the importance of found family and the slow development of trust and love within a small-town atmosphere.
Not sure what they've already read?
Let them pick their next favorite with an Amazon Gift Card.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
Callihan's writing style matches Scott's blend of sharp banter and deep emotional resonance. This story features a complex history between the leads that must be navigated as they find their way back to each other.
by Sally Thorne
For readers who enjoyed the snappy dialogue and the 'will-they-won't-they' energy of Adele and Pete, Thorne offers a quintessential contemporary romance filled with competitive banter and hidden longing.
by Lucy Score
This novel captures the small-town charm and the 'grumpy hero' archetype that fans of Kylie Scott often adore. It features a strong female lead finding herself in a new environment while dealing with complex family baggage.
This book shares the 'starting over' theme and the age-gap dynamic of Scott's novel. It is a deeply atmospheric and emotional journey about healing and finding love in unexpected places.
Like Scott’s exploration of past mistakes and second chances, this story follows a woman reconnecting with her first love years later, dealing with themes of betrayal, growth, and the passage of time.
For couples who love each other but hate planning
From chaos to calm — instant AI wedding planning, no accounts, no stress.
From the makers of Similar Book Finder
We earn from qualifying purchases through our affiliate partners, including Amazon and Bookshop.org.
