It Should Have Been You

Based on your book

It Should Have Been You

by Andrea Mara

Imagine sending a truly mortifying message – one packed with all your private thoughts about your neighbors – to the entire local community group chat by mistake. That cringeworthy scenario is just the fuse for Andrea Mara's It Should Have Been You, which quickly ignites into a full-blown suburban nightmare. What starts as social humiliation soon escalates into chilling threats, then a murder where the victim shares your exact address, just in a different part of town. The question isn't just who the killer is, but if they made a mistake that puts you next in line. This book is a masterclass in escalating tension, pulling you into a breathless race against time. It's for readers who love a psychological thriller that makes you question everyone, especially those living next door, and thrive on the unsettling feeling that a simple error can unravel your entire world.

10 Books similar to 'It Should Have Been You'

If Andrea Mara's It Should Have Been You left you craving more of that unsettling feeling when suburban veneers crack, we've curated a list just for you. These books share that compelling blend of psychological tension and the thrill of uncovering deep-seated secrets lurking beneath seemingly perfect lives. Whether it's the claustrophobic unraveling of small town mysteries or the race against time to expose a conspiracy, each recommendation will draw you into a world where trust is a luxury and every neighbor holds a potential key to the truth. Dive into these stories for more intricate puzzles and heart-pounding suspense.

We earn from qualifying purchases through our affiliate partners, including Amazon and Bookshop.org.

The Guest List

by Lucy Fokley

Fans of 'It Should Have Been You' will love this locked-room mystery set at a remote wedding, where a group of friends and family gather, only for one of them to turn up dead. Like Andrea Mara's work, it expertly unravels a web of secrets and past resentments among a tight-knit group, keeping you guessing until the very end.

Big Little Lies
Big Little Lies

by Liane Moriarty

This book delves into the complex lives of a group of mothers in a wealthy coastal town, where domestic secrets, friendships, and betrayals culminate in a shocking murder. Readers who enjoy Andrea Mara's focus on the dark underbelly of seemingly perfect lives and the dynamics within a female friend group will find this equally compelling.

The Last Thing He Told Me
The Last Thing He Told Me

by Laura Dave

When Hannah Hall's husband mysteriously disappears, leaving only a cryptic note, she must team up with his teenage daughter to uncover the truth behind his past. This fast-paced mystery, with its focus on a missing person and the unraveling of deep family secrets, offers the same thrilling, emotionally resonant experience as 'It Should Have Been You'.

The Girl on the Train
The Girl on the Train

by Paula Hawkins

This gripping psychological thriller features an unreliable narrator who believes she witnessed something crucial related to a missing woman, but her memory is hazy. The intense suspense, focus on memory and perception, and the unraveling of a dark mystery within a domestic setting will resonate strongly with fans of Andrea Mara.

Amazon Gift Card

Not sure what they've already read?

Let them pick their next favorite with an Amazon Gift Card.

Shop Gift Cards

As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

Before I Go to Sleep
Before I Go to Sleep

by S.J. Watson

Christine wakes up every day with no memory of her past due to a traumatic accident, relying on her husband to tell her who she is. When she starts secretly keeping a journal, she uncovers disturbing truths, mirroring the psychological suspense and deep-seated secrets found in Mara's work.

Local Woman Missing
Local Woman Missing

by Mary Kubica

This novel intertwines multiple perspectives and timelines to explore the disappearance of two women years apart in a small, seemingly idyllic town. Its focus on small town secrets, dysfunctional families, and the lasting impact of missing persons will appeal to readers who enjoy the intricate, dark mysteries of 'It Should Have Been You'.

The Woman in Cabin 10
The Woman in Cabin 10

by Ruth Ware

Journalist Lo Blacklock is on assignment aboard a luxury cruise when she witnesses a body being thrown overboard, but everyone insists no one is missing. This claustrophobic and suspenseful tale, featuring an increasingly unreliable narrator and a thrilling race to uncover the truth, shares the intense mystery and psychological tension of Mara's writing.

The Guest
The Guest

by B.A. Paris

When a friend from their past appears unexpectedly, a couple's seemingly perfect life begins to unravel as long-buried secrets resurface. This book masterfully builds tension through domestic suspense and explores the dark side of friendships and marital trust, much like the intricate relationship dynamics in 'It Should Have Been You'.

The Push
The Push

by Ashley Audrain

This dark and unsettling psychological drama explores the complexities of motherhood and the chilling suspicion that a child might be inherently evil. Readers who appreciate the psychological depth, disturbing themes, and exploration of dysfunctional family dynamics in Andrea Mara's work will find this a captivating and intense read.

My Lovely Wife
My Lovely Wife

by Samantha Downing

A suburban couple, bored with their marriage, decides to spice things up with dangerous games that quickly escalate out of control. This darkly humorous and disturbing thriller, with its focus on marital secrets, moral ambiguity, and unexpected twists, offers a similar blend of domestic suspense and psychological intrigue that fans of 'It Should Have Been You' will enjoy.