
Based on your book
by Lewis, Erika
Kelcie Murphy is a foster kid who has spent her life feeling like she does not belong anywhere. That changes the moment she is pulled into the Otherworld, a realm steeped in Celtic mythology where her true heritage and hidden powers begin to surface. This is a high-octane portal fantasy that hits the ground running and rarely lets up. The writing leans into the classic fish-out-of-water trope, but it is the sense of urgency and Kelcie's scrappy, relatable determination that keeps the pages turning. You are not just reading about a magical school or a quest for an artifact; you are following a girl who is finally finding her footing in a world that is as dangerous as it is beautiful. Perfect for readers who want a fast-paced adventure that balances epic stakes with the deeply personal quest for identity.
Since you enjoyed the thrill of Kelcie Murphy discovering her place in a hidden magical society, these picks focus on similar journeys of self-discovery and high-stakes mythology. Whether it is the portal-fantasy elements in Aru Shah or the intense school-based training found in The Iron Trial and Skandar, these stories mirror the feeling of an underdog stepping into their power. If you are looking for that same mix of ancient legend and modern-day grit, these books offer the perfect blend of world-building and character growth to keep your next reading adventure going strong.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
by Rick Riordan
Like Kelcie Murphy, this book features a young protagonist thrust into a hidden world of mythology and magic they never knew existed. Both stories excel at blending modern-day settings with ancient legends, creating an accessible and fast-paced adventure.
by B.B. Alston
This story mirrors Kelcie's journey of discovering her own hidden potential within a secret, magical society. It captures the same sense of wonder and the high stakes of a young girl trying to prove herself in a world that underestimates her.
by Holly Black and Cassandra Clare
Fans of the magic school setting and the feeling of being an outsider will appreciate this tale of a boy entering a dangerous world of elemental magic. It shares the same focus on friendship, complex loyalties, and the struggle to find one's place.
Drawing heavily on Hindu mythology, this book offers a similar portal-fantasy feel where a young girl accidentally unleashes ancient forces. The narrative voice is witty and engaging, much like Kelcie's, and focuses heavily on the responsibility of a young hero.

Not sure what they've already read?
Let them pick their next favorite with an Amazon Gift Card.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
This book features a protagonist who feels like a misfit until she is whisked away to a secret, magical city. It shares the whimsical, high-stakes atmosphere and the central theme of a young person discovering their true identity and unique powers.
by Kwame Mbalia
This story blends African American folklore with a high-stakes quest, echoing the way Kelcie Murphy integrates Celtic mythology. It deals with grief, resilience, and the power of storytelling, providing a similar emotional depth alongside the action.
This lyrical fantasy explores the discovery of magic and the weight of destiny, much like the journey Kelcie takes. It features a rich, immersive world and a young protagonist grappling with the complexities of her own power.
by Tracy Deonn
For readers who enjoyed the Celtic mythology aspects of Kelcie Murphy but want a slightly more mature, contemporary take, this book is perfect. It involves a secret society, hidden magic, and a protagonist uncovering deep family secrets.
This book features a unique magic system and a protagonist who is an underdog in a competitive, high-stakes environment. The pacing and the focus on training and discovery will feel very familiar to fans of Kelcie's adventures.
This story centers on a girl who discovers she has a rare, powerful ability that makes her a target, similar to Kelcie's experience. It balances the 'fish out of water' narrative with political intrigue and the struggle to understand one's place in a divided world.

Love to read on the go?
Explore Kindle e-readers and take your books with you.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.