Based on your book

Maui Murder

by Jasmine Webb

Maui Murder drops you right into Charlie's new life as a private investigator on the vibrant Hawaiian island. She's fresh to the game, and her first big case involves a baffling shooting, forcing her to untangle a web of secrets in a seemingly idyllic community. This isn't a dark, gritty mystery; instead, it's a delightful mix of puzzling clues, witty banter, and genuine heart. You'll find yourself cheering for Charlie as she navigates tricky situations with the help of some unexpected allies, all while trying to figure out her own path. It's a lighthearted, adventurous read that balances intrigue with a charming, sun-drenched atmosphere. Pick this up if you love a cozy mystery with a strong, relatable female lead, a dash of humor, and a compelling small-town puzzle that keeps you guessing.

10 Books similar to 'Maui Murder'

If Charlie's journey to becoming a PI amidst Maui's sun-soaked mysteries resonated with you, you'll find plenty to love in our curated recommendations. We picked these books for their shared spirit of adventure, featuring strong female leads who, much like Charlie, find themselves solving crimes in unique, often charming small-town or community settings. Whether it's the lighthearted humor, the intriguing local secrets, or the delight of an amateur sleuth discovering their knack for justice, these titles promise more cozy, character-driven mysteries that blend warmth with genuine suspense and unlikely friendships.

We earn from qualifying purchases through our affiliate partners, including Amazon and Bookshop.org.

Death by Dumpling
Death by Dumpling

by Vivien Chien

Like "Maui Murder," this book features a charming female protagonist who finds herself embroiled in a murder investigation in a unique community setting. Readers will enjoy the blend of lighthearted humor, culinary delights, and intriguing small-town secrets as the amateur sleuth navigates family dynamics and a puzzling crime.

A Caribbean Mystery
A Caribbean Mystery

by Agatha Christie

Fans of "Maui Murder" will appreciate the tropical island setting and the classic amateur sleuth at its heart, Miss Marple. This novel offers a more traditional yet equally engaging mystery with a strong sense of place, where a seemingly idyllic vacation spot hides dark secrets and a clever killer.

The No. 1 Ladies' Detective Agency
The No. 1 Ladies' Detective Agency

by Alexander McCall Smith

While set in Botswana rather than a resort, this series shares the charming, character-driven appeal and gentle mysteries of "Maui Murder." Readers will connect with the strong female lead, Precious Ramotswe, as she solves cases with wisdom and warmth, focusing on human nature and community bonds.

Arsenic and Old Grog

by S.C. Perkins

This book offers a very similar tropical cozy mystery experience to "Maui Murder," with a protagonist who moves to the Florida Keys to run a bar and quickly stumbles upon a murder. The blend of a new setting, quirky local characters, and a lighthearted investigative tone will resonate strongly with readers.

Amazon Gift Card

Not sure what they've already read?

Let them pick their next favorite with an Amazon Gift Card.

Shop Gift Cards

As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

A Deadly Inside Scoop

by Eva Gates

Readers who enjoyed the small-town charm and amateur sleuthing in "Maui Murder" will find a delightful parallel in this series set in a coastal North Carolina town. The protagonist, a librarian, uncovers local secrets and solves crimes, offering a cozy atmosphere and an engaging mystery.

One for the Money
One for the Money

by Janet Evanovich

For fans who enjoy the humorous and fast-paced aspects of "Maui Murder" with a strong, often clumsy female lead, Stephanie Plum's adventures are a perfect fit. While more of a comedic caper than a traditional cozy, it shares the element of an ordinary woman constantly stumbling into extraordinary trouble in her hometown.

Claws for Alarm
Claws for Alarm

by Cate Conte

This book captures the essence of a charming, animal-themed cozy mystery, much like "Maui Murder" captures a tropical one. The protagonist, a cat cafe owner in a small town, finds herself investigating a murder, providing a heartwarming atmosphere, quirky characters, and an engaging puzzle.

Purls Before Swine

by Maggie Sefton

If the community aspect and small-town secrets of "Maui Murder" appealed to you, this craft-themed cozy mystery will be a delightful read. It features a strong female lead who uses her connections within a close-knit knitting group to unravel a murder, blending warmth with intrigue.

Murder on the Menu
Murder on the Menu

by Penny Pike

Similar to "Maui Murder," this book offers a fun, food-centric cozy mystery with a spirited female protagonist who finds herself in the middle of a murder investigation in a charming small town. Readers will enjoy the blend of culinary delights, local color, and a puzzling crime.

Miss Dimple Disappears
Miss Dimple Disappears

by M.C. Beaton

For those who enjoy the classic British cozy mystery style with a charming small-town setting and an amateur sleuth, this book is an excellent choice. It shares the intriguing mystery and delightful character interactions found in "Maui Murder," but with a Scottish village backdrop.