Based on your book
My plain Jane
by Cynthia Hand
My Plain Jane takes the familiar, gothic bones of Charlotte Brontë's classic and injects it with a huge dose of humor, magic, and a whole lot of ghosts. You'll meet Jane Eyre, still a governess at Thornfield Hall, but this Jane can see the dead – and they're quite chatty. As she navigates Rochester's brooding mysteries and the strange happenings in the house, she finds herself tangled in an adventure far beyond her wildest expectations, complete with secret societies and a very unconventional romance. The reading experience here is buoyant and genuinely funny, full of witty banter and unexpected twists. It's a historical romp that feels fresh and modern, perfect for readers who love a strong, clever heroine and enjoy their historical fiction with a generous helping of the supernatural and a mischievous wink.
10 Books similar to 'My plain Jane'
If you found yourself utterly charmed by the witty historical revisionism and ghostly antics of My Plain Jane, you're in for more delightful reads. We've gathered books that share its irreverent humor, adventurous spirit, and love for turning classic tales on their head. You'll find more strong-willed heroines navigating magical or mysterious historical worlds, often with a generous side of unexpected romance. From its direct predecessor, My Lady Jane, to meta-fictional romps like The Eyre Affair, or even the original Jane Eyre to appreciate the brilliant parody, these picks deliver that unique blend of historical fun and supernatural flair.
We earn from qualifying purchases through our affiliate partners, including Amazon and Bookshop.org.
by Cynthia Hand, Brodi Ashton, and Jodi Meadows
As the first book in the 'Lady Janies' series, it shares the exact same irreverent, fourth-wall-breaking humor and historical revisionism. It reimagines the tragic story of Lady Jane Grey with a supernatural twist and a heavy dose of wit.
Since My Plain Jane is a direct retelling and meta-commentary on this classic, reading the source material is essential. It provides the foundational atmosphere of gothic mystery and the resilient spirit of the titular protagonist that the retelling parodies.
by Mackenzi Lee
This novel captures the same adventurous spirit and comedic historical tone found in the Janies series. It features a chaotic but lovable cast of characters navigating 18th-century Europe with modern sensibilities and romantic tension.
Fans of the meta-fictional elements of My Plain Jane will appreciate this story where literary detectives literally jump into the pages of Jane Eyre. It is highly imaginative, satirical, and deeply rooted in a love for classic literature.
Not sure what they've already read?
Let them pick their next favorite with an Amazon Gift Card.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
This book offers a similar blend of Victorian historical setting and a strong-willed female lead who defies social norms. It leans more into the gothic mystery and macabre elements that fans of the ghostly aspects of My Plain Jane will enjoy.
Much like My Plain Jane adds ghosts to a Brontë classic, this novel injects the supernatural into Jane Austen's world. It shares the same DNA of historical parody and action-packed revisionist storytelling.
by Mackenzi Lee
This sequel focuses on a female character's ambition and friendship, mirroring the camaraderie between Charlotte Brontë and Jane Eyre in My Plain Jane. It is a smart, fast-paced historical adventure with a feminist heart.
by Patricia C. Wrede and Caroline Stevermer
An epistolary novel that captures the whimsical and magical side of historical England. Its lighthearted tone and focus on the bond between two witty young women will resonate with fans of the Janies' narrative voice.
Set in a steampunk Victorian era, this book features a finishing school for spies and assassins. It matches the 'Janies' vibe of taking a historical setting and turning it on its head with humor and supernatural elements.
by Libba Bray
While slightly darker, this novel features a vibrant ensemble cast and a historical setting (1920s New York) infused with ghosts and the supernatural. It shares the 'team-up' dynamic and paranormal investigation themes.
For couples who love each other but hate planning
From chaos to calm — instant AI wedding planning, no accounts, no stress.
From the makers of Similar Book Finder
We earn from qualifying purchases through our affiliate partners, including Amazon and Bookshop.org.