Based on your book
by Stephanie Garber
Once Upon a Broken Heart pulls you into a vibrant, dangerous fairytale where wishes come with a price. Evangeline Fox, heartbroken and desperate, strikes a deal with Jacks, the enigmatic and treacherous Prince of Hearts. What begins as a simple bargain quickly spirals into a tangle of secrets, prophecies, and forbidden desires, all set against a richly imagined world of magic and intrigue. This book feels like stepping into a dream, both beautiful and unsettling, with a compelling slow-burn romance at its core. It's for readers who love intricate magic systems, a morally grey hero, and a story that constantly keeps you guessing what truth lies beneath the surface.
For those who were captivated by Once Upon a Broken Heart, we’ve curated a list of books that echo its unique blend of magic and romance. You’ll find more dangerous bargains with supernatural entities, protagonists navigating treacherous magical courts, and the irresistible tension of an enemies-to-lovers dynamic. Whether you’re drawn to the atmospheric whimsy, the intricate magic systems, or the high-stakes secrets and lies, these recommendations offer similar journeys into enchanting and perilous worlds.
We earn from qualifying purchases through our affiliate partners, including Amazon and Bookshop.org.
As the predecessor to Once Upon a Broken Heart, this series introduces the whimsical and dangerous world of the Fates. It shares the same lush prose, focus on sisterly bonds, and the atmospheric, game-like setting that fans of Evangeline Sallis will adore.
by Holly Black
This book captures the same sense of a mortal girl navigating a treacherous, magical court where deals are dangerous and nothing is as it seems. The dynamic between the leads mirrors the tension and moral ambiguity found in Evangeline's interactions with Jacks.
by Adalyn Grace
Fans of the 'bargain with a supernatural entity' motif will love this story about a girl who can communicate with Death. It features a similar gothic, romantic atmosphere and a mystery that keeps the reader guessing until the very end.
by Rebecca Ross
Like Garber's work, this novel features beautiful, lyrical writing and a deeply emotional core centered on magical correspondence. It captures the same sense of yearning and high-stakes romance set against a backdrop of mythological conflict.
Not sure what they've already read?
Let them pick their next favorite with an Amazon Gift Card.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
by Elise Kova
This story leans into the 'chosen bride' and 'magical bargain' tropes that drive the plot of Once Upon a Broken Heart. It offers a standalone fairytale-esque experience with a focus on a reluctant romance and a vibrant, magical world.
If you enjoyed the magical, dreamlike aesthetic and the sense of wonder in Garber's writing, this book is a perfect match. It focuses on a magical competition and a star-crossed romance that feels both timeless and ethereal.
This book features a protagonist who makes a dangerous alliance with a Prince of Hell to solve a mystery, much like Evangeline's deal with the Prince of Hearts. It is atmospheric, moody, and filled with romantic tension.
by Naomi Novik
This is a sophisticated retelling of fairytales that captures the 'be careful what you wish for' energy of Once Upon a Broken Heart. It features cold, fae-like beings and high-stakes bargains that test the protagonist's resolve.
For readers who enjoyed the more calculating and ambitious side of the characters, this 'Slytherin-romance' features a protagonist determined to woo and then kill a king. It shares the same fast-paced, plot-driven energy.
by Allison Saft
This book offers a unique magic system and a slow-burn romance that feels grounded yet whimsical. Fans will appreciate the atmospheric setting and the emotional depth of the two outsiders coming together for a common goal.
For couples who love each other but hate planning
From chaos to calm — instant AI wedding planning, no accounts, no stress.
From the makers of Similar Book Finder
We earn from qualifying purchases through our affiliate partners, including Amazon and Bookshop.org.