
Based on your book
by Callahan, Patti
Set in the shadow of post-war England, this story follows Megs Devonshire, a pragmatic college student whose younger brother, George, is terminally ill. George is obsessed with the origins of Narnia, and his persistent questions lead Megs to track down the author, C.S. Lewis. What follows is a quiet, tender exchange between a skeptical sister and a man who understands that stories are more than just ink on a page. The pacing is deliberate and gentle, mirroring the way grief forces us to slow down and find meaning in the smallest details. It is an exploration of how we use fiction to process the harsh realities of life. Readers who appreciate literary fiction that balances historical grounding with a touch of philosophical wonder will find this book deeply comforting and emotionally resonant.
Since you enjoyed how this book uses literature as a bridge between broken hearts, these selections are curated to keep that specific magic alive. We chose these titles because they echo the same profound belief that stories are essential tools for healing and connection. Whether you are looking for more historical settings that highlight the resilience of the human spirit or contemporary tales where books act as a catalyst for self-discovery, this list captures the same whimsical yet grounded emotional landscape found in George and Megs' journey.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
Like 'Once Upon a Wardrobe,' this novel celebrates the transformative power of literature and the deep connections formed through shared stories. Set in a atmospheric, post-war Barcelona, it captures a similar sense of mystery and literary enchantment that fans of C.S. Lewis's legacy will appreciate.
by Mary Ann Shaffer and Annie Barrows
This book shares the historical backdrop of the post-WWII era and emphasizes how books and storytelling can heal hearts and build communities. It features a warm, epistolary style that mirrors the gentle, character-driven focus found in Callahan's work.
by Neil Gaiman
This novel explores the thin veil between childhood wonder and adult reality, much like the way Callahan navigates the boundary between Narnia and the real world. Its lyrical prose and focus on memory and storytelling will resonate deeply with readers who enjoy magical realism.
by Jenny Colgan
Readers who loved the bibliophilic nature of 'Once Upon a Wardrobe' will delight in this charming story about the power of books to change lives. It offers a cozy, uplifting tone that focuses on the comfort found in classic literature.

Not sure what they've already read?
Let them pick their next favorite with an Amazon Gift Card.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
This is a gothic, literary mystery that revolves entirely around the importance of stories and the authors who create them. Fans of Callahan’s exploration of C.S. Lewis's life will enjoy this deep dive into the nature of authorship and family secrets.
by Sarah Penner
Featuring a dual-timeline structure, this novel weaves historical secrets with modern discovery, much like the way George’s search for the truth about Narnia unfolds. It captures the same sense of historical wonder and the weight of untold stories.
by Robin Sloan
This book is a love letter to the magic of books and the communities that form around them. It features a quest-like narrative that will satisfy readers who enjoyed the intellectual curiosity and sense of discovery in 'Once Upon a Wardrobe.'
This novel beautifully illustrates how books can serve as a bridge between people during times of grief and transition. Its focus on the emotional impact of literature and the redemption found in stories makes it a perfect companion to Callahan's work.
While more fantastical, this book shares the same lush, atmospheric writing style and the central theme of a world created through imagination and artistry. Readers who appreciated the 'magic' Callahan infused into her historical setting will be captivated here.
Set during World War II, this novel focuses on how people come together to sustain their spirits through art and shared purpose. It mirrors the historical setting and the emotional resilience found in 'Once Upon a Wardrobe.'

Prefer to listen?
Try Audible and hear the story instead of reading it.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.