Based on your book
P.S. I like you
by Kasie West
P.S. I Like You is the kind of book you pick up when you're in the mood for pure, unadulterated charm. It centers on Lily, who finds herself in an unexpected anonymous correspondence after doodling song lyrics on her chemistry desk. When someone replies, a secret letter exchange begins, blossoming into a deep connection built on shared tastes and vulnerabilities. The real hook here is the delicious tension of not knowing who your heart is falling for. Kasie West crafts a delightful mystery around this budding first love, making you root for Lily as she navigates school, friends, and the thrilling puzzle of her secret admirer. This is a wonderfully witty and lighthearted read, perfect for anyone who loves a good hidden identity romance, a bit of coming-of-age introspection, and a story that leaves you smiling. It’s a sweet, quick read that feels like a warm hug.
10 Books similar to 'P.S. I like you'
If you found yourself captivated by the charming mystery and sweet first love in P.S. I Like You, we have more stories that hit all the right notes. Our curated list focuses on books that share that delightful anonymous correspondence trope, where characters build deep connections through letters or messages before knowing who the other person truly is. You'll find plenty of witty banter, lighthearted romance, and the heartwarming journey of young adults navigating secret crushes and personal growth, just like Lily. These recommendations are perfect for readers who cherish the unique thrill of falling in love with a stranger's words.
We earn from qualifying purchases through our affiliate partners, including Amazon and Bookshop.org.
Like the anonymous letters in P.S. I Like You, this story features a protagonist who develops a deep connection with a mysterious stranger through digital messages. It captures the same sweet, nervous anticipation of falling for someone before you know their identity.
by Jenny Han
This book shares the same wholesome, endearing tone and focuses on the complications of written communication in romance. Fans of Kasie West's relatable female leads will find Lara Jean's internal monologue and family dynamics equally charming.
This is a slightly more emotional take on the 'anonymous correspondence' premise found in P.S. I Like You. It follows two teenagers who connect through notes left at a cemetery, sharing their deepest secrets while remaining strangers in real life.
by Jenn Bennett
A modern retelling of You've Got Mail, this novel features a 'hate-to-love' dynamic in person while the characters are unknowingly falling for each other online. It perfectly mirrors the dual-identity tension that makes Kasie West's writing so addictive.
Not sure what they've already read?
Let them pick their next favorite with an Amazon Gift Card.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
by Kasie West
For readers who loved the specific voice and pacing of P.S. I Like You, this other Kasie West favorite is a natural next step. It features her signature blend of lighthearted humor, low-stakes drama, and a sweet, evolving romance.
by Emma Lord
This book captures the witty banter and secret communication that fans of Kasie West adore. The protagonists are rivals in real life while unknowingly bonding through an anonymous chat app, creating a delightful 'will-they-won't-they' tension.
This novel is a gold standard for anonymous correspondence stories. It shares the same heart-pounding excitement of waiting for a message and the vulnerability of opening up to someone through writing rather than speech.
A modern, fandom-centric Cinderella retelling that relies on text-based communication between two people from very different worlds. It matches the optimistic and charming 'vibe' of P.S. I Like You while exploring themes of identity.
While it features adult protagonists, the witty banter and the premise of getting to know someone through their private messages will resonate with Kasie West fans. It is fast-paced, humorous, and deeply romantic.
by Cath Crowley
Set in a bookstore where people leave letters for each other in the pages of books, this novel captures the same magic of written connection as P.S. I Like You. It is a more reflective and atmospheric look at how words can bring people together.
For couples who love each other but hate planning
From chaos to calm — instant AI wedding planning, no accounts, no stress.
From the makers of Similar Book Finder
We earn from qualifying purchases through our affiliate partners, including Amazon and Bookshop.org.