Based on your book
P.S. I Like You
by West, Kasie
Lily Abbott is a songwriter who finds her creative outlet in the margins of her desk, scribbling lyrics that eventually spark a secret correspondence with an anonymous student. What begins as a shared love for music and witty banter turns into a high-stakes search for identity when she realizes her pen pal might be someone she already knows. The story moves with a breezy, energetic pace that mirrors the excitement of a burgeoning crush. West excels at capturing the specific, frantic joy of high school where a single note can change your entire outlook on the day. It is an ideal pick for readers who enjoy slow-burn tension, clever dialogue, and the comfort of a story that prioritizes genuine connection over manufactured drama. If you want a book that feels like a warm hug and a late-night text session, this is it.
10 Books similar to 'P.S. I Like You'
Once you finish Lily's story, you will likely find yourself craving more of that specific blend of anonymous connection and high school tension. We selected these ten titles because they master the same art of the secret identity and the digital or written romance. Whether it is the sharp, witty banter of an unexpected rivalry or the thrill of falling for someone whose face you have not yet seen, these books lean into the messy, heart-racing reality of first love. Each pick captures that same lighthearted, character-driven magic that makes a story impossible to put down.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
by Jenny Han
Much like P.S. I Like You, this novel centers on the consequences of secret written communication and the charming, messy process of falling in love. It captures the same lighthearted, high-school-romance atmosphere that fans of Kasie West adore.
This book features a delightful anonymous connection between two fans of a cult sci-fi show, mirroring the pen-pal dynamic of Kasie West's work. It is a sweet, witty, and heartwarming story about finding a kindred spirit in unexpected places.
This story shares the breezy, travel-infused romance style that Kasie West fans enjoy, focusing on personal growth and the excitement of new connections. It balances humor and emotion perfectly while keeping the narrative voice accessible and engaging.
Featuring a mysterious anonymous texter who helps the protagonist navigate a new school, this book offers the same 'mystery romance' hook found in P.S. I Like You. It is a quintessential YA contemporary read with sharp banter and emotional depth.
Love to read on the go?
Explore Kindle e-readers and take your books with you.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
by Kasie West
Since fans of P.S. I Like You naturally gravitate toward the author's other works, this title is a perfect follow-up. It features the signature snappy dialogue, relatable high school dynamics, and the classic 'fake dating' trope executed with charm.
by Emma Lord
This modern retelling of the enemies-to-lovers dynamic relies on digital communication, much like the letter-writing in P.S. I Like You. It is fast-paced, funny, and captures the specific tension of two people who don't realize they are talking to their rival.
by Lynn Painter
This book delivers the same swoon-worthy, cinematic romance experience that Kasie West fans crave. With a protagonist who loves rom-coms and a classic 'fake relationship' setup, it is consistently charming and emotionally satisfying.
by Jenn Bennett
This novel features a protagonist who falls for a boy online before realizing he is the same person she is clashing with in real life. It perfectly replicates the 'secret identity' and 'opposites attract' themes that drive the plot of P.S. I Like You.
While slightly more focused on family dynamics, this book captures the intense, all-consuming feeling of a first love that fans of P.S. I Like You will recognize. It is a beautifully written, romantic story that feels both realistic and magical.
This book excels at portraying the awkward, funny, and deeply relatable realities of high school romance. Readers who enjoyed the character-driven narrative and the sweet, slow-burn relationships in Kasie West's work will find this equally delightful.
Not sure what they've already read?
Let them pick their next favorite with an Amazon Gift Card.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.