Based on your book
by Sarah Adams
Practice Makes Perfect drops you right into the charming, slightly chaotic life of Annie, a florist in Rome, Kentucky, who is hilariously bad at dating. When the town's new, reserved doctor, Will, needs a place to stay, he ends up as her temporary roommate and, eventually, her "practice boyfriend." What starts as a series of awkward dating lessons quickly blossoms into something genuinely sweet and utterly delightful. This is a wonderfully witty and lighthearted read, full of laugh-out-loud moments and a slow-burn romance that will make your heart ache in the best way. It's perfect for anyone seeking a feel-good story with an endearing opposites-attract dynamic and a cozy small-town setting.
For those who adored Practice Makes Perfect, we’ve curated a list of books that capture its unique magic. If you found yourself charmed by Annie and Will's fake relationship turning real, or fell for the cozy, close-knit feel of Rome, Kentucky, you'll find plenty to love here. We've focused on stories featuring that delightful grumpy-meets-sunshine dynamic, clever fake dating setups, and the undeniable appeal of small-town settings where love blossoms unexpectedly. These recommendations offer more of that witty banter and heartwarming connection you cherished.
We earn from qualifying purchases through our affiliate partners, including Amazon and Bookshop.org.
by Sarah Adams
As the first book in the series, this provides the essential backstory for the small town of Rome, Kentucky. It features the same charming, sweet, and low-steam writing style that fans of Practice Makes Perfect adore, focusing on the romance between a pop star and a local pie shop owner.
by Sarah Adams
This book captures the same playful and wholesome energy found in Practice Makes Perfect. It focuses on a long-term friendship evolving into something more, utilizing the 'fake dating' setup that creates the same tension and yearning fans enjoyed with Will and Annie.
by Abby Jimenez
Like Practice Makes Perfect, this novel explores the 'fish out of water' dynamic in a cozy small-town setting. It balances humor with emotional depth, focusing on a protagonist who finds herself through a relationship with a man who is her complete opposite.
Fans who enjoyed the 'practice' aspect of Will helping Annie will love the fake dating arrangement here. It features a similar blend of witty banter, academic/professional settings, and a grumpy-meets-sunshine dynamic that creates a high-tension but sweet atmosphere.
Love to read on the go?
Explore Kindle e-readers and take your books with you.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
by Tessa Bailey
This book perfectly mirrors the 'city girl in a small town' vibe and the grumpy/sunshine character dynamic. The transformation of the protagonist as she learns to appreciate a slower pace of life echoes Annie's journey toward self-confidence and belonging.
by Emily Henry
This novel subverts typical romance tropes while leaning into a cozy, atmospheric small-town setting. The sharp banter and the deep emotional connection between the leads will resonate with readers who loved the chemistry and mutual respect in Sarah Adams' writing.
by Abby Jimenez
This story features a soft, high-anxiety protagonist similar to Annie and a male lead who is incredibly supportive and patient. The use of letters and fake dating to navigate social pressures provides a similar emotional resonance and 'pining' energy.
by Beth O'Leary
If you enjoyed the slow building of intimacy and the unique living situation in Practice Makes Perfect, this book is a perfect match. It features a quirky premise and a very sweet, respectful romance that prioritizes emotional connection and friendship first.
by Lynn Painter
Though technically YA/Crossover, this book captures the 'lessons in love' and 'fake dating' tropes with the same humor and heart as Sarah Adams. It focuses on a girl who enlists her neighbor's help to get her dream guy, only to find love where she least expects it.
by Tarah DeWitt
This hidden gem features a forced proximity situation involving a house renovation that forces two exes to reconcile. It shares the same cozy, small-town atmosphere and the gentle, character-driven pacing that makes Practice Makes Perfect so comforting.
Not sure what they've already read?
Let them pick their next favorite with an Amazon Gift Card.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
We earn from qualifying purchases through our affiliate partners, including Amazon and Bookshop.org.