
Based on your book
by Van Pelt, Shelby
Tova Sullivan is a woman who keeps her grief tucked away, finding comfort in the quiet, repetitive rhythm of her night shift cleaning the Sowell Bay Aquarium. Her most significant confidant is not a person, but Marcellus, a giant Pacific octopus with a sharp mind and a penchant for human observation. When the paths of a struggling young man named Cameron and the isolated Tova collide, they begin to untangle a decades-old mystery that has haunted the town. This book feels like a slow-burning hug; it is deeply reflective and moves with a gentle, deliberate pace. It is perfect for readers who appreciate character-driven stories where the emotional stakes are high but the delivery is understated, and who do not mind a touch of the whimsical to help ground the heavier themes of loss and family.
If the emotional resonance of Tova and Marcellus’s bond stayed with you, these selections were curated to keep that specific, heartwarming energy alive. We chose these titles because they excel at exploring the intersection of isolation and found family, much like Shelby Van Pelt’s narrative. Whether through the lens of grumpy protagonists finding their way back to humanity or intergenerational friendships that bridge deep divides, these books mirror the way a small community can fundamentally change a person. They prioritize quiet, character-led growth over high-octane plot, offering the same sense of hope and gentle resolution.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
by TJ Klune
Like Van Pelt's novel, this book features an unlikely protagonist finding unexpected connection and family in a world that feels both magical and deeply human. It shares the same gentle, heartwarming tone and focus on characters who feel like outsiders finding their place.
This novel mirrors the grumpy-yet-lovable protagonist arc found in Tova, exploring grief, isolation, and the transformative power of community. It balances melancholy and humor perfectly, much like the narrative voice in Remarkably Bright Creatures.
Readers who enjoyed the deep dive into Tova's internal life and her slow path toward healing will appreciate Eleanor's journey of self-discovery. It features a unique, somewhat isolated protagonist whose life is changed by unexpected social connections.
This book captures the same balance of sharp wit and genuine emotional depth as it explores grief and the formation of a makeshift family unit. It shares an intimate, character-focused narrative style that feels both grounded and deeply affecting.

Love to read on the go?
Explore Kindle e-readers and take your books with you.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
With its focus on how disparate lives intersect in surprising ways, this novel will appeal to those who loved the interconnectedness of the characters in Van Pelt's story. It is a compassionate look at human fragility and the threads that bind us together.
This story beautifully illustrates the bond between an elderly person and a younger person through the shared love of literature, echoing the intergenerational friendship at the heart of Remarkably Bright Creatures. It is a quiet, touching exploration of how we help each other heal.
Fans of the mature, thoughtful protagonist in Van Pelt's novel will enjoy Major Pettigrew, who navigates late-life changes and societal expectations with grace. It offers a similarly gentle, atmospheric setting where small moments carry significant emotional weight.
This book follows a woman who has spent her life in the background, much like Tova, as she finally steps into the spotlight to find her own agency. It is a poignant, character-driven story about starting over and the unexpected joy found in community.
by Ruth Hogan
This novel shares the theme of finding meaning in the small, often overlooked details of life, much like Marcellus the octopus observes the world. It is a gentle, interconnected story about grief, lost objects, and the people we connect with along the way.
by Libby Page
This story of an unlikely friendship between a young journalist and an elderly woman is deeply reminiscent of the bond between Cameron and Tova. It celebrates the importance of community spaces and the resilience of the human spirit.

Not sure what they've already read?
Let them pick their next favorite with an Amazon Gift Card.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.