Sometimes I Scare Myself

Based on your book

Sometimes I Scare Myself

by Jeneva Rose

Sometimes I Scare Myself is a collection that burrows into the uncomfortable corners of the human psyche. Jeneva Rose focuses on the jagged edges of domestic life, where the people we trust most are often the ones we should fear. The stories here rely on unreliable narrators and the crushing weight of family secrets to keep you off balance. You will not find comfort here; instead, you get a series of sharp, cynical looks at moral ambiguity and the ways our own minds can turn against us. The pacing is relentless, designed to make you question the stability of every character you meet. This is perfect for readers who prefer their thrillers dark and psychological, and who enjoy short, punchy narratives that leave a lingering sense of unease long after the final page is turned.

10 Books similar to 'Sometimes I Scare Myself'

If the unsettling atmosphere of this collection left you craving more, these selections are curated to keep that specific brand of dread alive. We chose these titles because they mirror the way Rose dissects domestic dysfunction and the rot hidden behind a normal facade. Whether you are looking for the sharp, cynical horror found in Shirley Jackson or the claustrophobic, high-stakes manipulation of B.A. Paris, these books lean heavily into the themes of family trauma and hidden agendas. They are essential reading for anyone who finds the most terrifying monsters to be the ones living right next door.

As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

The Lottery and Other Stories
The Lottery and Other Stories

by Shirley Jackson

Like Jeneva Rose's collection, this classic anthology masterfully explores the darkness lurking within ordinary life and small-town settings. Jackson's ability to craft unsettling, psychological horror with a sharp, cynical edge makes this an essential read for fans of short-form suspense.

Every Vow You Break
Every Vow You Break

by Peter Swanson

Swanson shares Rose's penchant for domestic thrillers that spiral into nightmare scenarios. This novel features the same sense of dread and psychological entrapment that readers of Rose's horror collection will find deeply compelling.

Her Body and Other Parties
Her Body and Other Parties

by Carmen Maria Machado

This collection blends horror, dark fantasy, and psychological realism in a way that mirrors the unsettling nature of Jeneva Rose's work. Readers who appreciate short stories that push boundaries and challenge perceptions of reality will find this collection equally gripping.

The Push
The Push

by Ashley Audrain

Fans of Rose's exploration of dark family dynamics and psychological tension will appreciate this debut novel. It delivers a visceral, disturbing look at motherhood and the secrets that can destroy a family, keeping the reader on edge throughout.

Amazon Gift Card

Not sure what they've already read?

Let them pick their next favorite with an Amazon Gift Card.

Shop Gift Cards

As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

Things We Lost in the Fire
Things We Lost in the Fire

by Mariana Enríquez

This collection of horror stories captures the same gritty, atmospheric dread found in Jeneva Rose's writing. Enríquez uses horror to dissect societal issues, providing a thought-provoking experience for readers who enjoy darker, more complex short fiction.

The Wife Between Us
The Wife Between Us

by Greer Hendricks and Sarah Pekkanen

This novel excels at the kind of twisty, psychological manipulation that fans of Jeneva Rose's thrillers crave. Its focus on complex relationships and hidden agendas provides a similar reading experience to the stories found in 'Sometimes I Scare Myself'.

North American Lake Monsters
North American Lake Monsters

by Nathan Ballingrud

Ballingrud's stories are deeply rooted in the horror of the mundane, much like Rose's collection. Readers who enjoy stories that start in familiar, relatable settings before descending into terrifying, psychological horror will appreciate this collection.

Verity
Verity

by Colleen Hoover

Known for its shocking twists and dark, psychological atmosphere, this book appeals to the same audience that enjoys Jeneva Rose's high-stakes suspense. It features a similar blend of romance and terror that keeps readers guessing until the very end.

Ghost Summer: Stories
Ghost Summer: Stories

by Tananarive Due

Due’s collection offers a masterclass in atmospheric horror that feels both intimate and terrifying. Fans of short-form horror will find the pacing and the focus on human frailty and dark secrets to be a perfect match for Rose's style.

Behind Closed Doors
Behind Closed Doors

by B.A. Paris

This novel is a quintessential example of the 'domestic thriller' genre that Jeneva Rose fans often enjoy. It creates an immediate sense of claustrophobia and dread, focusing on the dark secrets hidden behind a perfect facade.