Based on your book
by Megan Lally
Imagine waking up with no memory, completely disoriented, only to have a stranger claim you as his daughter. That's the unsettling start of Megan Lally's That's Not My Name. This book immediately pulls you into a disorienting haze, where every interaction feels laced with doubt. As the protagonist tries to piece together her past, another narrative unfolds, following a boy desperately searching for his missing girlfriend, Lola, while the town points fingers at him. Lally masterfully builds a tightly wound mystery, leaving you constantly questioning what's real and who to trust. It's a tense, psychologically driven read that will appeal to anyone who loves a good identity crisis wrapped in a thrilling, secrets-and-lies package.
If you found yourself gripped by the intense psychological mystery and the unsettling question of identity in That's Not My Name, we've got more reads for you. We handpicked these titles for their shared exploration of unreliable memories, the hunt for missing people, and the chilling reveal of long-buried secrets. You'll find protagonists navigating dangerous truths and the moral complexities of small towns, all while the clock ticks down. Expect the same heart-pounding suspense and intricate plots that make you question everything until the very last page.
We earn from qualifying purchases through our affiliate partners, including Amazon and Bookshop.org.
Like Megan Lally's work, this thriller features a determined protagonist unraveling a complex web of lies in a small town. It shares the same high-stakes energy and addictive pacing that keeps readers guessing until the final reveal.
by Kara Thomas
This gritty YA thriller mirrors the dark, atmospheric tension and psychological depth found in That's Not My Name. It focuses on the lingering trauma of past events and the dangerous search for the truth behind a series of local tragedies.
by Rose Carlyle
Fans of the identity-theft and gaslighting elements in Lally's debut will appreciate this intense psychological thriller. It explores themes of stolen identity and the blurred lines between truth and deception within a family.
by Alexa Donne
This book captures the same cutthroat, high-pressure environment and moral complexity seen in modern YA thrillers. It features a sharp narrative voice and a plot driven by secrets that spiral out of control.
Not sure what they've already read?
Let them pick their next favorite with an Amazon Gift Card.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
by April Henry
April Henry is a master of the 'teen in peril' subgenre that Megan Lally executes so well. This story involves a cold case and a protagonist who must navigate a dangerous path to uncover what really happened to a missing girl.
by Kimberly Jones and Gilly Segal
While focusing on different social issues, this book matches the 'race against time' urgency and intense, claustrophobic atmosphere of That's Not My Name. It forces two strangers into a high-stakes survival situation.
by Abigail Haas
This is a quintessential 'unreliable narrator' thriller that fans of Megan Lally's twists will find irresistible. It features a dark, psychological exploration of friendship and the terrifying possibility that you don't know the people closest to you.
This book offers a similarly bleak and gritty atmosphere with a focus on long-buried secrets and revenge. It captures the same sense of desperation and complex character motivations found in Lally's writing.
Readers who enjoyed the small-town mystery and the 'missing girl' trope in That's Not My Name will find this equally compelling. It balances multiple perspectives and layers of deception in a way that keeps the reader hooked.
by Tess Sharpe
This novel features a highly capable protagonist with a history of hidden identities, much like the themes of self-reinvention and survival in Lally's book. It is fast-paced, intense, and centers on outsmarting dangerous people.
For couples who love each other but hate planning
From chaos to calm — instant AI wedding planning, no accounts, no stress.
From the makers of Similar Book Finder
We earn from qualifying purchases through our affiliate partners, including Amazon and Bookshop.org.