
Based on your book
by Kasie West
When Gia's picture-perfect boyfriend dumps her right before prom, she's desperate to save face. In a moment of panic, she enlists a complete stranger to pretend to be her perfect guy. What starts as a simple fake dating scheme quickly spirals into a charmingly complicated adventure. Kasie West has a knack for crafting stories that feel like a warm hug, and this one is no exception. It’s a sweet, breezy read, full of humorous mishaps and genuinely heartwarming moments as Gia navigates the tricky waters of first love and figuring out who she really is, separate from any boy. You’ll find yourself smiling through this lighthearted journey of self-discovery, perfect if you’re in the mood for a feel-good romance with plenty of witty banter and a truly endearing cast of characters.
If The Fill-In Boyfriend left you craving more of that delightful blend of humor and heart, you're in luck. We handpicked these books because they capture that same irresistible spark. Many of them lean into the beloved fake dating trope, creating wonderfully awkward and ultimately sweet romantic entanglements. You'll also find stories that share The Fill-In Boyfriend's charmingly lighthearted tone, focusing on the joy and confusion of first love and the journey of self-discovery. Each one offers that comforting, feel-good reading experience you enjoyed, full of witty banter and endearing characters.
We earn from qualifying purchases through our affiliate partners, including Amazon and Bookshop.org.
by Jenny Han
Fans of 'The Fill-In Boyfriend' will adore this book for its iconic fake dating premise, where Lara Jean pretends to be in a relationship to avoid real feelings. It shares the same charming, lighthearted tone, focusing on first love, family dynamics, and the journey of self-discovery through a witty narrative voice.
This book offers a delightful blend of humor and romance, much like 'The Fill-In Boyfriend,' as it explores a modern take on arranged marriage that initially feels like a 'fake' or reluctant dating scenario. Readers will appreciate the cultural clash, witty banter, and the protagonists' journey of self-discovery as they navigate expectations and unexpected feelings.
by Emma Lord
For those who enjoyed the quick wit and contemporary feel of Kasie West's novel, 'Tweet Cute' delivers with its engaging online rivalry that subtly incorporates elements of a 'fake' or forced interaction. It's a fast-paced, humorous romance filled with charming banter, secret identities, and a focus on character growth and family businesses.
by Lynn Painter
This book is a perfect match for 'The Fill-In Boyfriend' fans, featuring a protagonist who enlists her childhood enemy to help her fake a relationship with another guy. It's a sweet, humorous, and deeply romantic story that plays with beloved rom-com tropes, focusing on first love, self-discovery, and overcoming personal challenges.

Love to read on the go?
Explore Kindle e-readers and take your books with you.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
While geared towards a slightly older audience, 'The Love Hypothesis' masterfully employs the fake dating trope with a witty, intelligent narrative voice that fans of Kasie West will appreciate. It's a charming, fast-paced romance set in academia, full of humorous situations and a heartwarming slow-burn connection between two unlikely individuals.
by Kasie West
As another Kasie West novel, this book shares the exact same charming writing style, lighthearted tone, and focus on high school romance that readers loved in 'The Fill-In Boyfriend.' It features a secret admirer plot that leads to mistaken identity and unexpected connections, offering a sweet and humorous journey of self-discovery.
by Emily Wibberley and Austin Siegemund-Broka
This book offers a delightful take on the fake dating trope combined with a second chance romance, making it a great recommendation for fans of 'The Fill-In Boyfriend.' It's a witty, lighthearted high school romance that explores personal growth and the complexities of first love through engaging characters and charming banter.
While not strictly a fake dating story, this book captures the same sweet, lighthearted, and charming essence as 'The Fill-In Boyfriend.' It's a fast-paced, character-driven romance focusing on a serendipitous meet-cute and the magic of first love, with themes of fate, family, and self-discovery that will resonate with readers.
by Sally Thorne
Fans of the witty banter and romantic tension in 'The Fill-In Boyfriend' will find a lot to love in this popular adult rom-com. It features a compelling enemies-to-lovers dynamic in a workplace setting, where initial animosity slowly gives way to a passionate and humorous slow-burn romance, driven by strong character voices.
This highly acclaimed novel takes the fake dating trope to a grander scale, evolving from a PR stunt into a genuine, heartwarming romance. Readers who enjoyed the humor and character-driven charm of 'The Fill-In Boyfriend' will be captivated by the witty dialogue, compelling characters, and empowering themes of self-discovery and forbidden love.

Not sure what they've already read?
Let them pick their next favorite with an Amazon Gift Card.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
We earn from qualifying purchases through our affiliate partners, including Amazon and Bookshop.org.