
Based on your book
by Barnes, Jennifer Lynn
Avery Grambs is living a quiet, unremarkable life until a billionaire she has never met dies and leaves her his entire fortune. The catch? She has to move into Hawthorne House, a sprawling, secret-filled mansion occupied by the man's disinherited family and his four enigmatic grandsons. You spend the entire book feeling like you are walking through a labyrinth where the walls might shift at any moment. It is fast, sharp, and deeply addictive, relying on constant riddles and a mounting sense of paranoia. Barnes excels at making you distrust every character while simultaneously wanting to know their darkest secrets. This is for the reader who wants a puzzle box of a book, someone who loves high-stakes drama, wealthy families with too much baggage, and a protagonist who is smart enough to hold her own against impossible odds.
If the puzzle-heavy atmosphere and the high-society tension of the Hawthorne family kept you up all night, these titles are your next logical step. We have curated this list to highlight stories where secrets serve as both currency and a weapon. Whether you are craving more elite school settings, dangerous games orchestrated by mysterious figures, or tenacious protagonists unraveling long-buried family histories, these books mirror that specific, sharp-edged suspense. Each selection captures the same feeling of being an outsider looking into a world where everything is a calculated move.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
Like Avery Grambs, the protagonist Stevie Bell is a sharp, observant outsider thrust into a high-stakes, puzzle-filled environment at a prestigious boarding school. The blend of a modern-day mystery intertwined with a cold case from the past will resonate deeply with fans of the Hawthorne House puzzles.
This book features a tenacious, intelligent female protagonist who dives into a dangerous investigation, mirroring Avery's relentless pursuit of the truth behind the Hawthorne inheritance. The fast-paced, addictive investigation style makes it a perfect follow-up for readers who enjoyed the high-stakes mystery of Barnes's series.
This novel captures the same 'high schoolers caught in a dangerous game' energy, where secrets are currency and everyone is a suspect. Fans of the Hawthorne brothers' complex dynamics will appreciate the character-driven tension and the web of lies that keeps the reader guessing.
Written by the same author, this book offers a similar exploration of high-society secrets and a fish-out-of-water protagonist navigating a world of immense wealth and deception. It features the sharp, witty dialogue and intricate plot twists that Barnes is known for.

Love to read on the go?
Explore Kindle e-readers and take your books with you.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
by Ellen Raskin
This is a classic puzzle-mystery that serves as the spiritual ancestor to The Inheritance Games, featuring a group of strangers brought together by a deceased eccentric billionaire's will. Readers who loved the riddles, games, and the race to solve the inheritance will find this essential reading.
by Alexa Donne
This thriller explores the cutthroat world of elite prep school admissions, echoing the competitive and often ruthless nature of the Hawthorne family. It captures the same feeling of 'wealthy teens behaving badly' and features a high-stakes mystery that keeps the tension mounting.
by Diana Urban
When a group of students is trapped in a room and forced to make impossible choices by a mysterious mastermind, the stakes become life-or-death, much like the games played at Hawthorne House. It is a tightly wound, suspenseful read that fans of the 'game' aspect of Barnes's work will devour.
by V.E. Schwab
While more atmospheric and gothic, this story of a girl uncovering the dark, hidden history of her family estate will appeal to fans who loved the eerie, puzzle-filled setting of Hawthorne House. It shares the same sense of discovery and the burden of a mysterious lineage.
by Kara Thomas
This gripping mystery centers on a girl trying to uncover the truth behind a series of tragic events in her town, echoing the way Avery must piece together the Hawthorne family history. It is a dark, character-focused thriller that rewards readers who enjoy unraveling complex, layered secrets.
This high-stakes thriller set in an elite private school features a 'game' orchestrated by an anonymous tormentor, mirroring the manipulative and dangerous atmosphere of The Inheritance Games. It combines social commentary with a fast-paced, twisty plot that fans of Barnes's work will find incredibly compelling.

Not sure what they've already read?
Let them pick their next favorite with an Amazon Gift Card.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.