
Based on your book
by Thompson, Marielle
Set in the shadowed, cobblestone corners of historical Edinburgh, this story follows a woman navigating the thin line between being a healer and a target. As the city tightens its grip on those who possess secrets that cannot be explained by science or faith, our lead character must balance her own survival with the dangerous allure of her heritage. The narrative moves with a slow, deliberate tension, mirroring the fog-drenched atmosphere of the Scottish capital. It feels less like a fast-paced fantasy and more like a historical haunting, where every whispered conversation carries the weight of a potential execution. If you enjoy stories that treat magic as a quiet, burdensome secret rather than a flashy tool, and if you appreciate prose that leans into the grit of the past, this will feel like coming home to a dark, beautiful nightmare.
Since you enjoyed the intersection of historical oppression and quiet, forbidden magic in this book, these titles serve as natural extensions of that experience. We have gathered stories that prioritize female agency in the face of superstition, whether through the lens of folklore, herbalism, or outright rebellion. If you found the atmospheric dread of Edinburgh compelling, look to The Familiars or Year of Wonders for a similar focus on how communities turn on the vulnerable. For readers who want to explore the internal life of the witch as an outsider, Circe and The Witch's Heart offer equally profound character studies.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
by Stacey Halls
Set against the backdrop of the Pendle witch trials, this novel mirrors the historical intensity and focus on female agency found in Thompson's work. It captures the same atmospheric dread and the precarious nature of being a woman with power in a superstitious society.
This novel shares the claustrophobic, historical setting and the sense of mystery surrounding a woman entering a new, strange environment. It features a similar blend of period-accurate detail and an underlying current of magical or uncanny occurrences.
Fans of the blend of folklore and historical setting will appreciate this story, which features a strong female protagonist navigating a world where ancient magic is fading. It offers a similarly lyrical writing style and a deep connection to the landscape.
For readers who enjoyed the Scottish setting and the intersection of history with the supernatural, this classic is an essential read. It features a similarly resilient protagonist thrust into a time and place where her knowledge makes her an outsider.

Love to read on the go?
Explore Kindle e-readers and take your books with you.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
This book focuses on the perspective of a marginalized woman in a world dominated by powerful, often cruel forces, much like the protagonist in Thompson's novel. It is a deeply emotional exploration of motherhood, survival, and identity.
This novel is a perfect match for readers who appreciate character-driven stories about women reclaiming their power despite societal exile. The lyrical prose and the focus on a solitary, misunderstood witch make it a thematic cousin to The Last Witch in Edinburgh.
by Sarah Penner
This novel weaves together historical and modern timelines, centering on women who use their knowledge of herbs and poisons to survive. It shares the same fascination with the secret, hidden lives of women throughout history.
While set in a different time period, this book shares the core theme of the 'witch' as an outsider and the struggle to fit into a judgmental community. It captures the same sense of sisterhood and the burden of inherited secrets.
This historical novel deals with a woman's resilience during a time of plague and hysteria, echoing the themes of persecution and survival found in Thompson's work. It is a gritty, realistic portrayal of how fear can turn a community against its own.
This story reimagines the history of witchcraft as a tool for political rebellion, which will resonate with readers who enjoyed the themes of oppression and agency in Thompson's book. It is a powerful, atmospheric tale of women finding their voice.

Not sure what they've already read?
Let them pick their next favorite with an Amazon Gift Card.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.