Based on your book
The Sundown Motel
by Simone St. James
The Sundown Motel pulls you into a chilling cold case as Carly Kirk takes a job at the very same rundown, isolated motel where her aunt went missing without a trace in 1982. You'll follow two timelines: Carly's present-day investigation as she uncovers unsettling clues and the haunting experiences of her aunt, Vivian, in the months leading up to her disappearance. This book excels at creating an oppressive, deeply atmospheric sense of dread, making the motel feel like a character itself, full of dark secrets and unsettling whispers. If you enjoy a mystery that slowly tightens its grip, blending small-town secrets with a palpable, ghostly unease and a determined female protagonist, this will keep you absolutely glued to the pages.
10 Books similar to 'The Sundown Motel'
For those who found themselves utterly absorbed by The Sundown Motel, these books offer a similar kind of atmospheric suspense. We've curated titles that share that distinctive feeling of a creepy, isolated setting holding dark secrets, whether it's a haunted house, a decaying mansion, or a remote island. You'll find compelling missing person cases, cold mysteries, and protagonists digging into past traumas, often structured with a dual timeline that slowly unspools the truth. If you crave that unsettling blend of psychological tension and the uncanny, these are your next reads.
We earn from qualifying purchases through our affiliate partners, including Amazon and Bookshop.org.
by Riley Sager
This book features a protagonist returning to her childhood home, a supposedly haunted house, to uncover the truth behind her family's past trauma and the mysteries surrounding the property, echoing the dual timeline and atmospheric investigation of "The Sundown Motel."
This novel delivers a rich, atmospheric gothic mystery set in an isolated, decaying mansion, where a determined young woman uncovers disturbing family secrets and horrors, much like Carly's investigation into the Sundown Motel's dark past.
As another work by Simone St. James, this book shares her signature blend of dual timelines, a creepy abandoned setting (a former reform school), a cold case mystery, and a hint of the supernatural, making it a perfect fit for fans.
by Ruth Ware
This book offers a claustrophobic, high-stakes mystery set on a luxury cruise ship, where a journalist witnesses a body thrown overboard but no one believes her, creating a tense atmosphere of secrets and an unreliable perspective akin to the psychological suspense in "The Sundown Motel."
Not sure what they've already read?
Let them pick their next favorite with an Amazon Gift Card.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
A foundational classic of psychological horror, this novel masterfully builds an oppressive, mysterious atmosphere around a supposedly haunted house and the fragile psyches of its inhabitants, appealing to readers who enjoyed the eerie, psychological tension of the motel setting.
by Lucy Fokley
Set on a remote Irish island during a wedding, this book presents a classic locked-room style mystery with multiple perspectives, where secrets unravel and a body is found, appealing to readers who enjoy intricate plots and a tense, isolated setting.
by Sarah Pearse
This thriller features an isolated, luxurious sanatorium-turned-hotel in the Swiss Alps, where a detective is trapped during a snowstorm and must solve a series of murders, providing a chilling atmosphere and a complex mystery similar to the Sundown Motel's confined secrets.
by Laura Dave
While less supernatural, this book delivers a compelling mystery centered on a woman trying to uncover the truth behind her husband's disappearance, featuring a strong female lead, deep family secrets, and a journey into the unknown, mirroring the emotional core of Carly's quest.
by Alice Feeney
This psychological thriller strands a couple in a remote, isolated chapel in the Scottish Highlands during a snowstorm, where their marriage secrets are exposed and a dark mystery unfolds, offering a tense, atmospheric, and twisty read similar to St. James's style.
by Alex North
This novel explores a chilling small-town mystery involving a serial killer and a father and son moving to a new, eerie house, blending psychological suspense with an atmospheric, dark tone and uncovering past crimes, much like the unsettling secrets of the Sundown Motel.
Love to read on the go?
Explore Kindle e-readers and take your books with you.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
We earn from qualifying purchases through our affiliate partners, including Amazon and Bookshop.org.