Then She Was Gone

Based on your book

Then She Was Gone

by Lisa Jewell

Lisa Jewell's "Then She Was Gone" pulls you into a deeply unsettling mystery, years after Laurel Mack's daughter, Ellie, vanished without a trace. Laurel is trying to rebuild her life when she meets a charming man, Floyd, whose young daughter, Poppy, is a dead ringer for Ellie. This isn't a fast-paced thriller, but a slow-burn psychological unraveling. You'll feel Laurel's lingering grief and the desperate hope mixed with a growing sense of dread as she digs into Floyd's life and the decade-old disappearance. It’s a haunting read for anyone who appreciates character-driven suspense, where the emotional toll of family secrets and the quiet horror of the unknown are as compelling as the puzzle itself. You'll be turning pages late into the night, desperate for answers.

10 Books similar to 'Then She Was Gone'

If "Then She Was Gone" left you craving more of those unsettling mysteries and deep dives into family secrets, we've got you covered. These recommendations share that same compelling blend of a missing person case, psychological tension, and the slow, often painful, reveal of hidden truths. Whether you’re drawn to the dual timelines, the emotional intensity of a mother's search, or the disturbing undercurrents beneath a seemingly normal life, you’ll find another story here to get lost in.

We earn from qualifying purchases through our affiliate partners, including Amazon and Bookshop.org.

The Silent Patient
The Silent Patient

by Alex Michaelides

Fans of "Then She Was Gone" will be captivated by this psychological thriller's intricate mystery and dark secrets. It masterfully explores the depths of human trauma and the shocking revelations hidden beneath a seemingly perfect surface, much like Jewell's exploration of a missing girl's past.

Gone Girl
Gone Girl

by Gillian Flynn

If you enjoyed the unsettling atmosphere and the 'missing person' trope in Jewell's novel, Flynn's masterpiece offers a similar dark dive into a marriage's hidden corners. It features a complex narrative with shocking twists and an unreliable narrator, keeping readers on edge until the very end.

The Girl on the Train
The Girl on the Train

by Paula Hawkins

This book shares "Then She Was Gone's" blend of a missing person case with deep psychological introspection and emotional intensity. The protagonist's unreliable perspective and the slow unraveling of a dark truth will resonate with readers who appreciate Jewell's character-driven suspense.

Before I Go to Sleep
Before I Go to Sleep

by S.J. Watson

For those who appreciate the psychological depth and secrets in "Then She Was Gone," this novel delivers a gripping narrative centered on a woman with amnesia. Her daily struggle to piece together her past, filled with unsettling discoveries, mirrors the intense emotional journey of uncovering hidden truths.

Kindle

Love to read on the go?

Explore Kindle e-readers and take your books with you.

Get a Kindle e-reader

As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

Big Little Lies
Big Little Lies

by Liane Moriarty

While less focused on a missing person, this book expertly weaves together the lives of women in a small town, revealing layers of secrets, domestic drama, and the dark undercurrents beneath a polished surface. Fans of Jewell's exploration of family secrets and the consequences of past events will find much to enjoy.

The Last Thing He Told Me
The Last Thing He Told Me

by Laura Dave

This compelling mystery, like "Then She Was Gone," centers on a woman searching for a missing person and uncovering profound family secrets along the way. Its strong female lead and emotional depth, combined with a propulsive plot, will appeal to readers who enjoy a heartfelt yet suspenseful journey.

Local Woman Missing
Local Woman Missing

by Mary Kubica

This novel is a perfect fit for fans of Lisa Jewell, featuring a dual timeline and multiple perspectives that unravel the mysterious disappearance of a mother and daughter. It delves into small-town secrets and the lasting impact of trauma, echoing the emotional resonance and suspense of "Then She Was Gone."

The Push
The Push

by Ashley Audrain

For readers who appreciate the dark psychological elements and exploration of motherhood in "Then She Was Gone," this novel offers an unflinching look at a mother's perspective on her challenging child. It's a disturbing yet compelling read about dysfunctional family dynamics and the secrets we keep, even from ourselves.

Home Before Dark
Home Before Dark

by Riley Sager

If you enjoyed the dual timeline and atmospheric mystery of Jewell's work, this book delivers with a story about a woman returning to her childhood home, infamous for being haunted. It masterfully blends psychological suspense with family secrets and a chilling atmosphere, keeping you guessing until the end.

The Good Daughter
The Good Daughter

by Karin Slaughter

This book will appeal to readers who appreciate the darker, grittier side of family secrets and trauma explored in Jewell's work. It follows a lawyer forced to confront a horrific past event, offering intense psychological suspense, a strong female lead, and a deep dive into the lasting effects of violence.