
Based on your book
by Reinhart, Larissa
Wannabe Detective is the kind of book that feels like catching up with a friend who always manages to get themselves into the most ridiculous predicaments. It follows a protagonist who is trying to find their footing in life, only to stumble headfirst into a mystery that is way above their pay grade. The tone is sharp, self-deprecating, and consistently funny, moving at a brisk pace that keeps the stakes feeling urgent without ever becoming heavy. It hits that sweet spot of a coming-of-age story where the character growth is just as important as the clues being uncovered. This is for readers who prefer their crime fiction with a side of sarcasm and heart, and who enjoy watching an underdog prove that being an amateur might actually be an advantage when everyone else is taking themselves too seriously.
Since you enjoyed the chaotic charm of Wannabe Detective, these picks were curated to satisfy that specific craving for amateur sleuths who are as relatable as they are determined. We have selected stories that balance high-stakes investigations with the messy, often hilarious realities of personal life, friendship, and family interference. Whether you are looking for the sharp wit of a reluctant detective or the cozy, community-focused puzzles found in the rest of our list, these books lean into the same underdog energy and clever banter that make Reinhart's work such a fun, fast-paced read.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
Like Reinhart's work, this book features an amateur sleuth navigating a chaotic life with humor and grit. The narrative voice is fast-paced and witty, perfect for fans who enjoy a relatable protagonist stumbling through a mystery.
by Alan Bradley
Readers who enjoy the quirky, determined spirit of amateur detectives will love Flavia de Luce. This book balances a clever, intricate mystery with a charming, distinct narrative voice that feels both intelligent and fun.
This novel shares the chaotic, high-stakes humor found in #WannabeDetective, centering on a protagonist dealing with family meddling while trying to solve a major problem. It perfectly captures the blend of suspense and laugh-out-loud comedy.
Fans of amateur sleuths dealing with local drama will appreciate this cozy mystery set in a restaurant. It features a strong sense of community, family dynamics, and a protagonist who finds herself in over her head, much like Reinhart's characters.

Not sure what they've already read?
Let them pick their next favorite with an Amazon Gift Card.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
For readers who enjoy the procedural side of mystery but still crave deep character work, this book offers a compelling narrative. While slightly more serious, it shares the focus on intricate puzzle-solving and the personal lives of those investigating the crime.
This book is a masterclass in the 'amateur sleuth' genre, offering a witty and heartwarming look at friends solving crimes. Fans of #WannabeDetective will appreciate the clever dialogue and the focus on unlikely heroes.
by Kate Lansing
This cozy mystery features a protagonist trying to balance a career with amateur investigation, mirroring the relatable struggle found in Reinhart's writing. It is light, engaging, and perfect for readers who love a good 'whodunit' with a side of personal growth.
This book leans into the humorous side of the mystery genre, featuring a protagonist who is constantly dealing with chaotic family events while trying to solve a crime. It shares the same energetic, fun-loving tone as #WannabeDetective.
by Louise Penny
While it has a slightly more literary and atmospheric tone, this book is essential for fans of character-driven mysteries. The sense of community and the focus on the internal lives of the villagers will resonate with those who enjoy the setting and character dynamics of cozy mysteries.
This book takes the 'amateur sleuth' trope to a hilarious and suspenseful extreme. Fans of #WannabeDetective will love the protagonist's relatable chaos, the fast-paced plot, and the way the story balances crime with everyday life struggles.

Love to read on the go?
Explore Kindle e-readers and take your books with you.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.