We Used to Live Here

Based on your book

We Used to Live Here

by Marcus Kliewer

Imagine settling in for a quiet night, only for strangers to appear at your door, claiming your house used to be theirs. That's the unsettling start to Marcus Kliewer's We Used to Live Here. This isn't a jump-scare kind of horror; it's a slow, creeping dread that wraps around you as the lines between truth and manipulation blur. Kliewer crafts a story steeped in intense psychological suspense, where the threat feels intimately close and the mystery deepens with every interaction. You'll feel the tension mount, the isolation closing in, and the chilling power dynamics at play. It’s a book for readers who relish dark, atmospheric tales, where secrets unravel slowly and the true horror lies in what people are capable of, and the insidious ways trust can be broken.

10 Books similar to 'We Used to Live Here'

If We Used to Live Here left you with that particular chill, yearning for more stories where the threat feels uncomfortably close to home, these books are for you. We've gathered titles that excel at building an unsettling atmosphere and exploring the insidious nature of secrets and lies. Whether you're drawn to the psychological dread of a house with a mind of its own, the slow unraveling of sanity, or the chilling realization of evil lurking beneath a normal facade, you'll find a kindred spirit here. These recommendations all share that pervasive sense of tension and isolation that made Kliewer's book so compelling.

We earn from qualifying purchases through our affiliate partners, including Amazon and Bookshop.org.

The Haunting of Hill House
The Haunting of Hill House

by Shirley Jackson

Fans of Kliewer's unsettling atmosphere and psychological dread will find a masterclass in terror within this classic. Jackson expertly crafts a house that feels malevolent, slowly unraveling the sanity of its inhabitants through subtle, insidious horror rather than overt scares, mirroring the growing unease in "We Used to Live Here."

House of Leaves
House of Leaves

by Mark Z. Danielewski

Readers who appreciate the experimental, deeply unsettling, and meta-narrative aspects of Kliewer's work will be captivated by this unique horror novel. It delves into the psychological impact of an impossible house, creating a sense of profound disorientation and dread that goes beyond traditional haunted house tropes.

Mexican Gothic
Mexican Gothic

by Silvia Moreno-Garcia

For those who enjoyed the atmospheric dread and the sense of a grand, sinister history embedded in a location in "We Used to Live Here," this book offers a rich, gothic experience. It features a decaying mansion filled with dark family secrets and a growing sense of claustrophobia and danger, wrapped in a lush, historical setting.

Penpal
Penpal

by Dathan Auerbach

Originating from creepypasta, this novel shares a direct lineage with the internet-inspired horror of Kliewer's work, offering a similar brand of slow-burn, deeply unsettling dread. It weaves together fragmented childhood memories to uncover a disturbing mystery, creating a pervasive sense of unease and psychological horror.

Kindle

Love to read on the go?

Explore Kindle e-readers and take your books with you.

Get a Kindle e-reader

As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

A Head Full of Ghosts
A Head Full of Ghosts

by Paul Tremblay

This novel will appeal to readers who appreciate the psychological depth and unreliable narration in "We Used to Live Here," as it masterfully blurs the lines between mental illness and supernatural possession. It's a chilling exploration of family trauma and the terrifying ambiguity of what's real, told through a compelling, multi-layered narrative.

Rosemary's Baby

by Ira Levin

Fans of the slow-burn paranoia and the feeling of being trapped in a malevolent situation, as experienced in "We Used to Live Here," will find this a chilling read. It's a masterclass in psychological suspense, where a woman's growing dread and isolation within her own home lead to a terrifying realization about the forces surrounding her.

The Southern Book Club's Guide to Slaying Vampires

by Grady Hendrix

While featuring vampires, this book shares "We Used to Live Here's" focus on domestic dread and the insidious nature of evil lurking beneath a seemingly normal facade. It captures the chilling realization of a threat within one's own community and home, blending small-town secrets with a slow-burn horror that builds to a thrilling climax.

Imaginary Friend
Imaginary Friend

by Stephen Chbosky

Readers who enjoyed the unsettling, supernatural presence and the mystery surrounding a new, creepy location in "We Used to Live Here" will be drawn to this story. It builds a pervasive sense of dread through a child's perspective, exploring a small town haunted by an ancient, malevolent entity and the psychological toll it takes.

Come Closer
Come Closer

by Sara Gran

For those who appreciate the psychological unraveling and the slow, insidious descent into horror found in "We Used to Live Here," this novel offers a terrifyingly intimate experience. It's a chilling first-person account of a woman's growing belief that she is possessed, blurring the lines of reality and creating a deeply unsettling atmosphere of dread.

Ghost Story
Ghost Story

by Peter Straub

This literary horror classic will appeal to those who enjoyed the complex, deeply atmospheric mystery and the pervasive sense of dread in "We Used to Live Here." It weaves together multiple perspectives to uncover a decades-old secret and a malevolent supernatural entity haunting a small town, building a rich tapestry of dread and suspense.