Based on your book
by Sarah Adams
Imagine a pop star, utterly burned out from her glamorous life, ditching it all for a quiet escape, only to land in a charmingly unexpected small town. That's the delightful setup for When in Rome, where Amelia Rose finds herself stranded and reluctantly taken in by Noah, a gruff but secretly soft-hearted pie shop owner. This book delivers a truly cozy and heartwarming reading experience; it's like settling into a warm blanket with a cup of tea. Sarah Adams excels at crafting witty banter and a slow-burn romance that feels genuinely sweet and earned. If you love a story where a big-city character finds unexpected joy and love in a tight-knit community, complete with grumpy-sunshine dynamics and a cast of quirky small-town characters, this is a perfect pick for a feel-good afternoon.
For readers who fell for the charming 'fish out of water' story in When in Rome, where a high-profile city dweller finds unexpected romance in a cozy small town, you'll find plenty to love in our curated list. Many of these recommendations share that delightful dynamic of opposites attracting, often featuring a city-smart protagonist clashing with a grumpy, endearing local. You'll also discover that comforting small-town atmosphere and the slow-burn emotional connection that makes Sarah Adams' writing so heartwarming and memorable.
We earn from qualifying purchases through our affiliate partners, including Amazon and Bookshop.org.
by Sarah Adams
As the direct companion to When in Rome, this story follows Noah's sister Annie and features the same cozy Kentucky setting. It maintains the sweet, closed-door romance style and focuses on a charming fake-dating scheme that fans of the original will love.
by Tessa Bailey
This story features a high-profile socialite who is sent to a small Pacific Northwest town and falls for a grumpy local sea captain. It mirrors the fish-out-of-water dynamic and the grumpy-sunshine trope that fans of Amelia and Noah will adore.
by Abby Jimenez
This novel explores the relationship between a high-powered city doctor and a younger, small-town carpenter. It captures the same 'worlds colliding' theme and the comforting, community-focused atmosphere of Rome, Kentucky.
by Sarah Adams
Also by Sarah Adams, this book delivers the same witty banter and heartwarming energy. It features a sweet, low-steam romance between best friends that captures the author's signature lighthearted tone and focus on emotional connection.
For couples who love each other but hate planning
From chaos to calm — instant AI wedding planning, no accounts, no stress.
From the makers of Similar Book Finder
by Emily Henry
Set in a picturesque town, this story involves two opposites who find themselves in a forced proximity situation. It shares the same blend of humor, emotional depth, and small-town charm found in Adams' work.
by Lucy Score
This book features a famous YouTube house flipper who arrives in a small town and meets a local landscaper who challenges her. It echoes the 'celebrity meets regular guy' dynamic and the process of finding where you truly belong.
by K.A. Tucker
A city girl travels to remote Alaska and clashes with a rugged, grumpy pilot. It perfectly captures the fish-out-of-water experience and the gradual softening of a grumpy hero in a tight-knit community.
by Jen DeLuca
Set during a Renaissance Faire in a small town, this story features a protagonist who finds herself at odds with a local man. It shares the quirky, community-driven vibe and the lighthearted humor of When in Rome.
When Georgie returns to her hometown to figure out her life, she ends up house-sitting with a grumpy hermit. It focuses heavily on personal growth and finding love in unexpected places, much like Amelia’s journey.
This story features a female bodyguard protecting a famous actor, flipping the script on the celebrity trope. It maintains a sweet, humorous, and heartfelt tone that will resonate with fans of Sarah Adams.
Love to read on the go?
Explore Kindle e-readers and take your books with you.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
We earn from qualifying purchases through our affiliate partners, including Amazon and Bookshop.org.