
Based on your book
by Scott Tracey
Witch Eyes introduces you to Braden, a young man whose world takes an unexpected turn when he discovers he possesses a unique, unsettling magical ability – the 'witch eyes' of the title. This isn't a gentle introduction to magic; it's a plunge into a hidden, often dangerous, world where secrets cling to everyone and everything. As Braden grapples with his newfound powers and the truth about his own identity, he's forced to navigate a mysterious society he never knew existed, all while trying to understand where he fits in. The book has a propulsive, intriguing pace, pulling you along with Braden's emotional journey of self-discovery. It feels like uncovering a conspiracy alongside a friend, full of heart and genuine wonder, even as the stakes rise. If you love stories about outsiders finding their place, rich magic systems, and the thrill of uncovering deep-seated secrets, this one will keep you turning pages well into the night.
If Witch Eyes resonated with you, particularly its blend of a young protagonist discovering a hidden magical identity and navigating first love, then our curated list offers more of that compelling magic. We sought out books that share its heartfelt exploration of self-discovery and acceptance, often featuring queer characters finding their place in secret worlds. You'll find stories brimming with intricate magic systems, deep-seated secrets, and the emotional journey of an outsider coming into their own, whether they're battling ancient evils or simply learning to love themselves.
We earn from qualifying purchases through our affiliate partners, including Amazon and Bookshop.org.
Fans of "Witch Eyes" will adore this book for its charming blend of a gay protagonist discovering his magical destiny, navigating a hidden magical world, and falling for his supposed nemesis. It captures the same vibrant energy, emotional depth, and thrilling first love experience, all set within a captivating magic school environment.
by Aiden Thomas
This book offers a compelling narrative featuring a trans Latinx brujo who summons a ghost and falls in love, echoing the themes of discovering one's true magical identity and navigating a hidden world. It shares "Witch Eyes'" heartfelt exploration of self-acceptance, family secrets, and a passionate, magical romance.
Readers who enjoyed the mysterious atmosphere and the discovery of a hidden magical world in "Witch Eyes" will be captivated by this series. It features a group of compelling characters, including psychics and those seeking ancient magic, embarking on a quest filled with secrets, found family, and a unique, atmospheric charm.
by T.J. Klune
While an adult novel, this heartwarming story shares "Witch Eyes'" spirit of an outsider discovering a magical hidden world and finding where they truly belong. It features a charming M/M romance and themes of acceptance, found family, and overcoming prejudice, all wrapped in a wonderfully whimsical and hopeful tone.

Not sure what they've already read?
Let them pick their next favorite with an Amazon Gift Card.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
This quintessential YA urban fantasy series is perfect for readers who loved the idea of a hidden magical society and a protagonist discovering their latent powers. It's packed with action, romance, and intricate lore, following a young woman who uncovers her true identity and battles demons, much like Braden's journey into the world of witches.
by Ransom Riggs
For those drawn to the concept of unique, hidden abilities and a secret world, this book presents a compelling mystery about a boy who discovers a hidden orphanage for children with extraordinary powers. It blends a dark, atmospheric tone with themes of found family and self-discovery, reminiscent of Braden's journey with his "witch eyes."
This novella explores a school for children who have returned from portal worlds, each with their own unique experiences and often peculiar abilities. Fans of "Witch Eyes" will appreciate the themes of identity, finding belonging among other "peculiar" individuals, and the underlying mystery, all with strong queer representation.
While a heist fantasy, this book offers a diverse ensemble cast with unique magical abilities navigating a gritty, hidden criminal underworld. Readers who enjoyed the intensity, complex power dynamics, and found family aspects of "Witch Eyes" will appreciate the intricate plotting, high stakes, and compelling character relationships, including queer representation.
by Lev Grossman
For readers who enjoyed the concept of discovering a hidden magical world but desire a more mature, complex, and sometimes cynical take, this book is an excellent choice. It delves into the realities of magic and the challenges of being a "chosen one," exploring themes of self-discovery and disillusionment with a darker, thought-provoking tone.
Though it lacks magic, this book masterfully captures the emotional core of "Witch Eyes": a gay teenager grappling with a significant secret, navigating first love, and the journey of coming into his own identity. The heartfelt romance, authentic voice, and themes of self-discovery and acceptance will deeply resonate with fans.

Love to read on the go?
Explore Kindle e-readers and take your books with you.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
We earn from qualifying purchases through our affiliate partners, including Amazon and Bookshop.org.